Known for its slogan, We Buy Ugly Houses, HomeVestors of America is one of the nation’s largest franchise cash home buyers.
Local franchise owners can purchase homes in any condition, pay in cash, and close in as little as three weeks — making HomeVestors a solid option for sellers facing financial challenges, tight timelines, or properties in poor condition.
That said, working with HomeVestors comes with a significant financial tradeoff. The cash offer is generally well below market value, and some franchises have faced complaints and negative publicity over their business practices.
If you’re planning to request an offer from HomeVestors, it’s smart to compare its offer with a few others before deciding. Sellers with multiple offers to fall back on tend to get far better outcomes.
To save yourself some time, consider starting with Clever Offers. With Clever, you can compare legitimate cash offers from top-rated iBuyers, local investors, and more. Recent sellers who compared offers with Clever saw an average price gain of +$66,735. Submit a quick form to find your best offers — no added fees or pressure to move forward.
Who does HomeVestors work best for?
Pros
- Sell your house as is, regardless of its condition
- Close in as little as 3 weeks
- Established, nationally-recognized brand
- Easy process — no repairs, staging, or showings
Cons
- Offers are typically a lot less than market value
- Customer experience may vary across locations
Companies like HomeVestors make the most sense when you have a home that you need to sell quickly, and you aren’t concerned with getting the highest price possible. For example, you might consider HomeVestors if you:
- Need to move on an extremely tight timeline
- Have a house in poor condition
- Are facing foreclosure or other financial issues
- Need to sell an inherited home
- Are selling a house from out of state
- Don’t have time or money for home repairs
- Own a rental property with problematic tenants
In these situations, HomeVestors offers a distinct advantage over a traditional home sale: An all-cash offer with no contingencies and the ability to close on your own timeline. They'll also purchase your house as-is, do all of the repairs, and cover the closing costs. In many cases, you can even leave unwanted furniture behind.
Just be prepared to take a significant financial loss for the ease of being able to walk away and leave the work to someone else.
Cash home buyers like the ones who operate HomeVestors need a steep discount off their purchase price in order to earn a profit when they sell a home at market value later on.
"Most of the time, it makes more sense to work with an agent," says Charles H. Chandler III, CEO and co-founder of My Tennessee Home Solution. "If someone just wants to skip out on agent fees, I would not recommend calling an investor because offers will be lower than just what the agent fees are." This is especially true given the emergence of low commission brokerages that are changing the standards for realtor fees.
However, Chandler says working with an investor can be the right move when "someone wants to close quickly and needs some creative solutions to get a house sold." He also points to inherited properties as a common use case: "It is a much quicker sale and investors typically let you leave everything behind in the house."
Does HomeVestors make good offers?
To get an accurate gauge of how much HomeVestors offers for homes, we asked a homeowner in suburban New York City to request an offer as a secret shopper.[1] Two local realtors independently ran comparative market analyses on her 1,200-square-foot Cape-style home and estimated a listing price of $434,500.
After an in-person walk-through of our secret shopper's home and property, HomeVestors' offer came in at $301,200 — roughly 31% below its estimated market value. Even after accounting for approximately $33,000 in closing costs and commissions on a traditional sale, our shopper would have netted about $401,500 with an agent — approximately $100,000 more than the HomeVestors offer.
This gap is fairly typical of how cash investors approach pricing. Clever Real Estate's 2024 survey of over 700 real estate investors found that flippers typically adhere to some version of the 70% rule, which says to estimate the home's after-repair value based on comparable home sales in the area, multiply that number by 70%, and subtract the projected repair costs to arrive at the offer price. Our 2026 investor survey showed similar results, with most investors capping their offers between 70 and 75% of a home's after-repair value.
Based on our 2026 survey of real estate investors (n=21). Note that 4 investors did not specify a fixed percentage. Figures are a share of ARVARV is what a home is expected to sell for after it's fully fixed up and renovated. before rehab and closing costs are deducted, so actual offers fall below these percentages.
That said, investors may adjust ARV up or down based on the condition of the property, the areas it's in, and what they plan to do with it (i.e., flip it or rent it out).
"We can justify offering near the top of our range when a home needs only cosmetic updates, is located in a strong neighborhood with low inventory, and can be resold quickly with minimal risk. On the other hand, we'd offer closer to the lower end when a property requires major structural work, has foundation or environmental issues, complicated title problems, or is located in an area with slower resale activity. Higher risk requires a larger financial cushion because unexpected costs are almost inevitable."
Tariq Thomas, Owner, Yes I Pay Cash - We Buy Houses
HomeVestors reviews and complaints
Rating distribution
Theme breakdown
Click on a theme to see related reviews.
Reviewers describe patient, caring franchise reps who guided them kindly through stressful sales like inherited or downsized homes.
Sample reviews
Reviewers describe an easy, straightforward sale with no surprises, hidden fees, or hassle from start to close.
Sample reviews
Reviewers describe honest, upfront reps who stood by their word and delivered exactly what was promised without surprises.
Sample reviews
Reviewers describe receiving fair cash prices, some comparable to a realtor sale, with no commissions or repair costs.
Sample reviews
Reviewers describe quick closings, sometimes within days or weeks, with flexible timing that fit their moving needs.
Sample reviews
Reviewers describe reps who explained each step clearly, answered questions promptly, and kept them informed throughout the sale.
Sample reviews
Some reviewers describe persistent unsolicited mail, calls, and texts that continued despite repeated opt-out and removal requests.
Sample reviews
Some reviewers describe unresponsive or rude reps, missed appointments, no-shows, and offers that changed or fell through.
Sample reviews
What recent HomeVestors customers have to say
We analyzed 1,622 recent HomeVestors reviews (all reviews since 2023) across 3rd-party platforms like BBB, Google, and Yelp. Positive reviews mention the professionalism of the company reps, who are described as honest, transparent, and accommodating. Sellers also praise HomeVestors reps for their flexibility and accommodation in difficult situations, such as when selling a home as is from out of state. However, your experience with HomeVestors may vary based on location. Reviews for certain branches point to questionable sales tactics, such as pressuring vulnerable customers to sell. Scattered reviews also mention low offers compared to competitors.
What recent reviewers talk about
Sentiment analysis of 1,622 HomeVestors reviews (all reviews since 2023), classified by AI
Filter by reviewer type
Click a segment to see what that group talks about most.
Top themes across all reviewers
Top HomeVestors alternatives
HomeVestors is one of the most recognizable cash home buying brands in the nation. However, it's important to shop around to ensure you're getting a competitive offer. Doing so gives you negotiating leverage and improves your chances of getting a better deal.
How HomeVestors works
Here's what to expect when selling your home through HomeVestors:
- Complete an online form to book a no-obligation home review.
- Confirm your details with the company. Then, your local branch will reach out to schedule a walkthrough.
- Once the walkthrough is complete, you’ll receive a cash offer — sometimes on the same day.
- You can accept the cash offer and move to the closing process or deny the offer and walk away.
- Close on your home in as little as three weeks.
Our secret shopper described the process of requesting an offer this way:
"I called the number on the mailer they had sent me and had an appointment scheduled within a week. The evaluator arrived on time, professionally dressed in a company-branded shirt, and carried a checklist during the home tour. Before the home tour, we sat down to talk briefly about why I wanted to sell, when I was hoping to move, and what I was looking for in terms of an offer."
Our shopper noted that the rep was surprisingly transparent about the tradeoffs of selling to a cash buyer, "telling me I would probably get more money if I were to sell it the traditional way using a real estate agent." However, he also emphasized the convenience of a cash sale with no contingencies, no inspection, and no risk of financing falling through.
Within 15 minutes of completing the walkthrough, the evaluator presented a written offer for $301,200, which was more than $100,000 off from the listing range of $400,000–469,000 that two independent realtors had suggested.
Once the offer was on the table, there was little room for negotiation. "I gave them an opportunity to come back with a better number, but they were unwilling to do so," our shopper reported.
While our secret shopper ultimately declined the offer, she gave HomeVestors high marks for their professionalism and communication, noting that there was no pressure from her local rep to move forward: "He was very gracious. He said he understood, and in no way tried to talk me into accepting it.
HomeVestors fees and other costs
There’s no upfront cost to seek an offer from HomeVestors, and the company doesn’t charge any fees or commissions. The cash buyer also covers closing costs.
However, these costs will be baked into the offer price, along with the estimated renovations cost and the investor's desired profit margin.
What types of homes does HomeVestors buy?
HomeVestors specializes in purchasing homes that most buyers won't. This includes houses that are distressed, structurally unsound, located in flood zones, or occupied by tenants. Some franchisees may also purchase multi-unit and commercial properties. However, mobile homes on leased lots may not be eligible for an offer.
📍HomeVestors locations
HomeVestors is available nationwide. Select your local market to find additional cash offer products available near you.
Is HomeVestors legitimate?
HomeVestors of America, Inc. was founded in Dallas in 1996 and maintains an A+ rating with the BBB.
Although HomeVestors (more popularly known as "We Buy Ugly Houses") has been a prominent cash-for-homes company for nearly three decades, recent years have brought significant scrutiny.
A 2023 ProPublica investigation found that some franchisees exploited vulnerable homeowners — particularly the elderly and those facing financial hardship — to acquire properties under questionable circumstances.[2]
For example, home seller Maria Jimenez reported feeling pressured by her local franchise to sell, stating they warned her that the city might take her home if she didn't agree to the sale — just a day before a social worker was scheduled to assist with code violations.[3]
The fallout prompted CEO David Hicks to step down, and the company has since cycled through leadership. Joshua Waltzer now serves as CEO.[4]
In 2024, HomeVestors introduced reforms including revised training materials, an anonymous reporting platform for franchisees, and a three-day opt-out period for sellers.[5]
However, questions about franchise oversight persist. In May 2025, former top-performing franchisee Charles Carrier pleaded guilty to federal wire fraud after running a Ponzi-like scheme through his Dallas franchise that defrauded approximately 80 investors of nearly $40 million. HomeVestors terminated his franchise in October 2024 and reported him to the FBI, but investors have questioned why the scheme went undetected for nearly two decades.[6]
That said, our secret shopping experience painted a rosier picture of HomeVestors' day-to-day professionalism and transparency, with our shopper noting that "the person I met with was honest and upfront about how the company works." As with any franchise, your experience will depend heavily on your local operator — always vet their reviews and track record before signing a contract.
How to evaluate an offer from HomeVestors
Because there’s no fee to seek a cash offer from HomeVestors — or obligation to accept it — it doesn't hurt to request an offer to compare against a few others. But you’ll want to look beyond the purchase price.
- Know your home value. “Clarify how the cash offer compares to your property’s retail market value. If possible, get a comparative market analysis (CMA) from a realtor,” says investor Brian Harbour, Senior Acquisition Manager at Real Deal Home Solutions. “Factor in saved costs like repairs, commissions, and closing fees to evaluate if the cash offer is truly advantageous.”
- Find out if you're dealing with the end buyer. Some companies that present themselves as direct buyers are actually wholesalers who put your home under contract and then sell that contract to another investor for a higher price than what they're offering. Wholesaling adds another party to the transaction, and there may be loopholes that let the investor out of the contract if their buyer falls through. Look for language that refers to the "buyer and/or assigns" or clauses that allow the investor to market the home while you're under contract. While wholesaling isn't necessarily bad, you may want to ask for a higher earnest money deposit to ensure you're protected.
- Make sure all the key details are in the contract. The earnest money deposit, sale price, closing date, inspection period, and other key terms should be clearly stated in the purchase agreement. If it’s not in writing, you’ll have no recourse if the buyer makes last-minute changes or backs out of the deal altogether.
- Ask for proof of funds. Also, ask for a proof-of-funds letter from the buyer's banking institution verifying that the buyer has sufficient funds to cover the transaction costs. A legit and experienced cash buyer should be happy to give this to you.
- Make sure there's a meaningful earnest money deposit. A deposit gives the buyer skin in the game. Investor Igor Avratiner of We Buy Houses Philadelphia says he typically puts down 1–2% of the sale price, though he's flexible for sellers who want more assurance. "We've had people say, 'I need you to put down $20,000 because if you back out, this is going to jam me up.' And we'll do that."
- Be wary of an offer that's significantly higher than others. “The biggest thing to look out for is when an investor tells you a price much higher than other offers,” says investor Charles Chandler. “It is likely that the offer is a bait and switch tactic, which means they will lock you in on a price that sounds good but will come back before closing to price drop.”
- Remember that getting a cash offer isn’t an either/or scenario. You can get offers from cash home buying companies to use as a baseline. Then, set your terms with a listing agent and give them a timeframe to beat your highest offer. That way, you'll know for sure what buyers are willing to pay and can be confident that you’ve made an informed decision without leaving money on the table. Getting even one or two competing offers could net you significantly more from your home sale.
Recommended Reading
About our reviews
Our review process includes gathering all verifiable customer reviews from 3rd party sites such as BBB, Google, Consumer Affairs, TrustPilot, and Yelp. In addition to tallying total review counts and average customer ratings, we run all available reviews through AI to identify the most common positive and negative themes mentioned across the entire review set.
Whenever possible, we also talk directly to customers, company reps, and industry professionals (such as real estate agents) who have firsthand experience with the company.
For our HomeVestors review, we consulted the following sources:
- A secret shopper based in suburban New York, who requested an offer from the company and met with a HomeVestors sales rep at her home
- Charles H. Chandler III, CEO and co-founder of My Tennessee Home Solution
- Igor Avratiner, Franchise licensee at We Buy Houses Philadelphia
- Brian Harbour, Senior Acquisition Manager at Real Deal Home Solutions
- We also reached out directly to HomeVestors' corporate office, but they declined our request for comment
Clever Real Estate, the publisher of this review, also owns Clever Offers, which partners with investors and iBuyers across the country to provide sellers with cash offers from a network of vetted buyers. While we offer a competing cash offer product, we value editorial integrity. We give advice that we would follow ourselves or offer to family and friends. We believe in the quality and value of our offerings, but also recognize that our products won't always work for everyone, which is why Clever Offers is one of several options we present to readers seeking a cash sale. There's no pressure to work with Clever Offers or any company we connect you with through our marketplace. We want you to choose the best option for your situation, whether that's through us or not.