The traditional home selling process doesn't work for everyone. In New York, a typical home sale can take 119 days from listing to closing. Some homeowners can't wait that long.
Enter "we buy houses for cash" companies.
These, and other types of cash buyers, offer a fast solution for homeowners. They purchase houses "as-is" — that is, in their current condition, without any repairs or prep — and pay in cash, so sellers don’t have to wait for a buyer to get a mortgage approval. The process is quick, easy, and requires no repairs or home prep.
For home sellers who need to sell in a hurry, want to avoid repair costs, or are looking for a more convenient selling method, a cash buyer can be a great option. But they're not right for everyone.
To ensure a profit, "we buy houses for cash" companies make offers that are well under fair market value. The speed and convenience they offer doesn't always outweigh the hit you could take to your bottom line.
In this article, we explain how "we buy houses" companies work, review five legitimate companies in New York, and break down examples to help you understand how much you can make selling to a cash buyer compared to other alternatives.
Read on to make an informed decision — and maybe find the buyer for your home!
While the smaller details and timeline varies from company to company, "we buy houses for cash" companies all share a basic business model.
- After being contacted by an interested home seller, the cash buyer assesses the property, focusing on factors like necessary repairs and the potential resale value.
- Based on the amount of time and money they'll need to invest in the property, the investor makes an "as-is" cash offer.
- If the homeowner accepts, the deal can close quickly because there's no need to negotiate, wait for financing approval, or inspect and appraise the property.
- The cash buyer repairs the home and then resells it for a profit.
The quick process benefits homeowners who don't have the resources or time for a traditional sale.
For perspective, in New York houses typically spend 74 days on the market before the seller accepts an offer. Then there's the closing process, which takes between 30 to 45 days if the buyer is applying for a mortgage. That means it can take the typical seller up to 119 days to finalize the sale.
In comparison, some "we buy houses for cash" companies in New York can complete the whole process in as few as 7 days.
Traditional Home Selling Timeline vs. "We Buy Houses for Cash" Companies
|Prepping the House||Time to Offer||Closing Process|
|Traditional Process||Depending on the condition of your home, repairing and preparing it for sale can take months.||74 days.||30-45 days|
|"We Buy Houses for Cash" Process||Not necessary. These investors buy homes "as-is".||Once the company evaluates the home, it often makes an offer within 24 hours.||As few as 7 days in New York|
Many "we buy houses for cash" companies advertise that they'll send you an offer in as few as seven minutes. This is not an official offer.
After talking to a company representative, they'll give a ballpark estimate of what they'll pay. Very few investors will make a binding offer sight-unseen — and if they do it'll be substantially lower to account for possible issues.
Once you schedule an in-person inspection, the investor will present a legal offer, often on the spot.
Also, know some of the bigger, well-known companies aren't the actual buyers. They are a network of local investors, or they collect interested sellers' information and pass it on to flippers. In these cases, how long the process takes will depend on the investor in your area.
For example, we called five "we buy houses for cash" companies that advertise offers in less than an hour — none of them responded within that time frame.
We Buy Houses Companies in New York: Reviews
Local Cash Buyers in New York
Check out the following links to find out more information about "we buy houses for cash" companies in your specific area.
How Much Will We Buy Houses for Cash Companies in New York Pay?
"We buy houses" companies use the 70% rule to ensure they'll make a profit. Basically, the 70% rule says the buyer shouldn't pay more than 70% of the home's After Repair Value (ARV) — what they hope to sell the house for — minus repairs.
Selling a House to a Cash Buyer in New York: 2 Examples
"We buy houses for cash" companies use home values of comparable properties to estimate ARV. Assuming your house is the same size and has the same layout as most homes in your area, your city's average home value is more or less the ARV a cash buyer is shooting for.
However, the cost of necessary repairs will significantly impact the offer you receive.
For many sellers, being unable to pay for repairs limits their options. You need to consider whether paying for repairs out-of-pocket is an option before deciding to sell to a cash buyer.
Let's look at some examples of cash offers a home seller could expect in different New York cities versus what it would cost to pay for repairs out-of-pocket.
Home in Yonkers in Need of Major Repairs
Say your home is in Yonkers, where the average home value is $544,414. Your house needs a new roof (average repair cost: $1,221), a kitchen remodel ($24,341), foundation repairs ($3,108), and sod installed on the lawn ($2,126).
Here's how a cash buyer will calculate their offer:
|70% of ARV||$381,090|
|Cost of Repairs||$30,796|
|Max. Cash Buyer Offer||$350,294|
Cost of repairs based on HomeAdvisor Local averages (June 2020)
The offer may seem low, but most homeowners don't have almost $31,000 to pay for the repairs. In addition, more extensive repairs can easily get out of hand and exceed the average (i.e. a kitchen remodel with new cabinets, counters, and appliances can cost upwards of $50,000).
To avoid that out-of-pocket expense and the risk of spending more than you'll get back, in this example, it's understandable why a seller would accept an offer that is about 36% below fair market value.
If the cost of fixing your home is similarly high, selling to a "we buy houses for cash" company may be your best option.
Home in New Rochelle in Need of Minor Repairs
In New Rochelle, the average home value is $674,833. If your house needs minor repairs like new carpeting ($1,263) and a fresh coat of paint ($3,493), here's how a cash buyer will calculate their offer:
|70% of ARV||$472,383|
|Cost of Repairs||$4,756|
|Max. Cash Buyer Offer||$467,627|
Cost of repairs based on HomeAdvisor Local averages (June 2020)
In this case, the total cost of professional repairs is $4,756, but the offer is 31% below fair market value.
Instead of selling to a "we buy houses" company and losing almost $208,000, it might be a better option to pay for the repairs, make some minor fixes yourself, or offer traditional buyers a repair credit.
Are "We Buy Houses for Cash" Companies Scams?
Many "we buy houses for cash" companies in New York are safe and completely legal. They provide a valuable service to homeowners who need to sell their homes quickly or can't afford to make repairs. Many local cash buying companies are family owned and work with sellers to meet their closing and moving timelines.
That being said, as with any industry, there are bad apples. If a "cash buyer" approaches you, check that they have an established web presence and customer reviews before giving them your personal information.
Also read all the fine print on any contract they present you. Look up words or terms you don't understand. And never assume the contract says what you agreed to verbally.
Most importantly, look at the contract's contingencies. These are the conditions that allow the buyer to back out of the sale or change the terms. Unless you understand the contingencies, you could be taken advantage of.
How Much Does Selling to a Cash Buyer Cost?
Every real estate transaction has costs that can add up quickly. Expenses like closing costs, repairs, and real estate agent commissions can eat away at your profits.
Luckily, when you sell to a "we buy houses for cash" company, you avoid many traditional selling costs like:
- Realtor commissions
- Closing costs
- Seller concessions
When you add all these expenses up, selling to a cash buyer can have significantly fewer costs than a typical home sale. However, given the lower sale price of selling to a "we buy houses" company, the savings don't always make up the difference.
Let's take a look at four different ways to sell your home and how the costs compare:
Selling Cost Comparison in New York
|Selling to a "We Buy Houses" Company||Selling with Clever||Selling with a Traditional Realtor|
|Sale price (compared to fair market value)||70% max.||100%||100%|
|Commissions/Service Fees^||0%||1% listing fee + 2.3% buyer's agent commission||4.8-5.6%|
|Max Take Home||70% max||94% max||93% max|
^New York seller concessions and commission rates based on a Clever survey of 500+ real estate agents
Many cash buyers advertise that home sellers do not have to pay for repairs. And it's true. You don't have to open your wallet and pay for a contractor or repair supplies. However, since cash buyers take on these costs themselves, their offers are lower to make up the difference.
So when selling your home, consider the different ways necessary repair costs impact your bottom line — both positively and negatively.
|Typical Repair Cost||Pros||Cons|
|Making Repairs Before Listing||Varies based on home's condition.||You can list your home for more.||No guarantee your final sale price will cover the cost of the repairs.|
|"We Buy Houses" Company||Varies based on home's condition. But the more that needs to be done, the lower their offer will be.||No hassle of dealing with contractors and no uncertainty of paying for repairs that don't lead to a higher sale price.||As professional house flippers, "we buy houses" companies can have repairs done for less than you. However, their offer may not reflect the discount they receive.|
|Offering Repair Credits||In New York, sellers typically agree to $5,000+ in repair credits.||Instead of paying for repairs, a credit passes the responsibility and risk to the buyer.||There are limitations on how you can offer repair credits. Depending on the buyer's lender, you might have to write a check to a contractor chosen by the buyer.|
+Based on a Clever survey of 500+ agents; 65% in New York said repair credits rarely exceed $5,000.
Many homeowners sell to a "we buy houses for cash" company because speed is their biggest priority. They might need to sell quickly to avoid foreclosure or to get out from under the costs of owning an unwanted property, also known as carrying costs.
Every day you wait to close your sale, you lose money on carrying costs. Here's how those costs break down in New York.
Average Carrying Costs in New York
|Mortgage Payment: $44|
|Homeowners Insurance: $5|
|Property Taxes: $16|
|Total Cost per Day: $88|
Now let's look at how these costs can add up depending on how long it takes to sell your home in New York.
Total Carrying Costs
|Selling Method||Time to Offer||Time to Close||Carrying Costs|
|"We Buy Houses for Cash"||1 day (pending home evaluation)||7-30 days||$704-$2,728|
|Traditional Agent||74 days||30-45 days||$9,152-$10,472|
|Clever Partner Agent||13 days*||30-45 days||$3,784-$5,104|
*Based on the average time it takes for homes listed with Clever to receive an offer
Total Selling Costs in New York
Let's get down to brass tacks: How much can you expect to make selling your home to a cash buyer versus with an agent on the open market?
Looking at an example with actual numbers will help you see if selling to a "we buy houses for cash" company is really worth it for your situation.
Here's how much a seller in New York can walk away with using the state's median sale price of $363,000 and its average selling cost rates (closing costs, repair costs/credits, carrying costs, etc.).
New York Cost Breakdown
|Selling to a "We Buy Houses" Company||Selling with a Traditional Realtor||Selling with Clever|
*Based on the 70% rule and assuming the house needs 10% of its ARV in repairs
^Based on HomeAdvisor national average
Pros and Cons of We Buy Houses For Cash Companies in New York
- Fast, certain cash offers: After viewing your home, most "we buy houses for cash" companies will give you an offer within 24 hours. And unlike other buyers, there's no chance of the deal falling through because a mortgage application is denied or the buyer getting cold feet.
- Sell your home "as-is": If you don't have the time or money to make significant repairs to your house, a "we buy houses for cash" company could be your best option. While their offer will account for the cost of repairs, they'll buy homes regardless of their condition.
- Schedule your own closing date: Instead of going through the typical 30-45 day closing process, you can schedule a day to close in as few as 7 days.
- Low closing costs: Most "we buy houses for cash" companies will cover typical closing costs. This can save you 1-3%.
- Lower offers: Cash buyers are property investors. To ensure they make a profit, their offers will likely follow the 70% rule (at most 70% of the home's ARV, minus the cost of repairs).
- No negotiating: You can either take an offer from a "we buy houses for cash" company or leave it. They don't negotiate, even if you disagree with their evaluation of the property.
- Predatory tactics: Many sellers considering a cash buyer are in a difficult situation. You might be facing foreclosure or not have enough money to sell the traditional way. "We buy houses" companies know this and some might try and take advantage of your situation. Never sign anything because you feel pressured and be prepared to walk away if something doesn't feel right.
Alternatives to We Buy Houses for Cash in New York
Many homeowners turn to "we buy houses for cash" companies because they think it's their only option. They need to sell quickly and can't afford to make repairs.
However, there are other ways to sell fast without sacrificing the amount of money you make off the sale.
In general, it takes longer to sell a house with an agent than to sell directly to a cash buyer. But there are realtors who specialize in quick sales. With a little research, you could find an experienced agent who can sell your home "as-is" in a matter of days.
Hiring an agent does mean paying commissions, which can eat into your profits. In New York, expect to pay 4.8-5.6% of your sale price in realtor fees.
>> LEARN more about real estate commission
Clever can connect you with top agents in New York based on your unique needs. If you need to sell your house fast, Clever will put you in touch with a local agent who has proven they can get offers in a matter of days, or even hours.
Plus, with Clever you save on listing commissions meaning more money in your pocket at the end of your sale.