Agent portrait unavailable

Spencer Schumacher

Top Agent

Spencer Real Estate Group

Madison, WI

Recent sales

128

Price range

$140K - $1.6M

Typical price

$440,000

Active since

N/A

About Spencer Schumacher - Madison, WI real estate agent

Spencer Schumacher is a top real estate agent in Madison, WI with Spencer Real Estate Group. They work with sellers and buyers and have closed at least 65 transactions over the past 12 months — 128 over the past two years. Spencer Schumacher's experience includes first-time homebuyers, luxury homes, and new construction.

Agent info

License info

Name
Spencer Schumacher
License
58017-90 (WI)

Reviews for Spencer Schumacher

Real Estate Professional • Spencer Real Estate Group • Madison, WI

5.0 135 reviews on

Note: Some reviews may be for team members.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy and sell homes • Madison, WI • 2024

Spencer's team went above and beyond! I had a fantastic experience with them when I purchased a home, and went right back to them when it came time to sell. They knew exactly what needed to be done and the best time to get the house up on the market. I was bombarded by extraordinary offers after one weekend of showings, and closed on the house without a hitch! If you're looking to sell or buy in their area, I highly HIGHLY recommend this team.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • Towne Deforest, WI • 2023

Holy cow!!! This was our first home purchase, it was far from standard(in my opinion) and this team was AH-mazing. We couldn't have been more impressed or thankful. Shoutout to Spencer, Aaron, Lacey, and I know everyone else helped behind the scenes. They regularly checked up on us (but it wasn't too much), they stayed patient with all of our questions, crazy ideas and the many listings we wanted to see on short notice. Despite not sure we were ready to buy. They were a wealth of valuable advice as we toured homes with their extensive knowledge from the industry, our town, their past careers, and of course their own home adventures. Everyone worked to find answers if they weren't readily available and had great response time. They work as a smooth team to keep us informed about every step of the process, and were grinding down to the wire when there were a lot of unknowns with our situation and we needed to pull it all together to close. Spencer was there through walk-though and closing to give us moral support and again answer any outstanding questions, plus they've checked in since closing! In an era where it's easy to disconnect, I really appreciated all the personal touches Spencer's team does. Buying a home is a big deal, and it's clear Spencer Real Estate Group loves what they do by the care they took for us. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • 2023

Spencer and his team worked diligently to assist me in buying a home. They were communicative, patient, friendly, and resourceful. They helped narrow my search and visit numerous properties. This process helped immensely because it allowed me to prioritize what I was looking for. Once I found my home, they made the closing process as simple as possible. Spencer also offered to help me re-rent my apartment prior to the closing date. This was an amazing experience from start to finish and I look forward to working with them again in the future.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Listed and sold a home • Madison, WI • 2023

We worked with Spencer Real Estate Group for both buying and selling and had a great experience. They were responsive and provided excellent service and coordination throughout the whole process. One thing that really stood out during selling was the staging guidance, photos, 3D models, and other marketing work that really was a step above my experience with other realtors. I would definitely recommend the Spencer team to others!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • Madison, WI • 2023

I highly recommend Spencer Realty. They quickly respond to my questions and requests to see a property, are knowledgeable about the market, and they point out problems with a home’s condition and ballpark costs for repair. I find them to be honest, polite and personable. Their team approach works well. They didn’t give up on me after viewing at least a dozen homes. I am now living in a house that fits me thanks to the Spencer Realty team.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • 2023

We had an amazing experience working with Spencer, Aaron, Faith, Lacey, and the entire team! The entire team was kind, helpful, and instrumental in helping us navigate a busy market to find the right home for us! During showings they were quick to point things out and give us insights on items that may need to be addressed. When making offers, Spencer helped work within our parameters while providing guidance based on market trends. When we needed to change approach in a competitive market, Spencer was clear with ways to make our offer more competitive. He did this without us once feeling pushed or pressured to make a change we would be uncomfortable with. We will be recommending Spencer and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell their homes!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • Madison, WI • 2022

Spencer and his team were amazing. They are quick to respond and know how to work this ever fluctuating market. They are with you every step of the way. Spencer's knowledge of home construction is invaluable when viewing homes and his negotiating skills leave you knowing that if it he couldn't get it, no one could have. We have purchased two homes with Spencer and his team, and will continue to recommend them to friends and family.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Listed and sold a home • Madison, WI • 2022

Everything about Spencer Real Estate Group is exceptional. When they say that they work as a team, they genuinely mean that they meet every day to discuss your transaction in and out to make sure that everything is on track and to see if there is anything extra that they can do for your family. We bought and sold a home with Spencer Real Estate Group and could write a novel about how well this team cared for us. It's hard to put into words just how well they found the perfect balance - we felt like they were our best friends but were also true professionals through every step of the process. Every phone call, email, and face to face interaction felt genuine and they knocked our socks off with how well they also knew the market. To give a few shout outs... SPENCER - A true leader and market expert. On the buying side, he was a fierce yet fair negotiator. On the selling side, he listened to our wants and needs and gave suggestions to increase value without overwhelming us with "to-do's". I have never met a professional or person with a straighter moral compass. It's clear that he had our best interest in mind from day one and was willing to put in the extra work regardless of the situation. Spencer and his team helped us receive 16 amazing offers with incredible contingencies and our preferred closing date! ERIK - He handled the pre-listing timelines and media package that was included in the listing (for freeeee!) and he was outstanding. Respectful, conversational, and always willing to bend over backwards to help (literally...sorry about the furniture that needed to be shifted). LACEY - Once we had a quick accepted offer, she ran the show with logistics! She was always two steps ahead of us and answered every question quickly and thoroughly - a true transaction angel. AMANDA - The unsung hero of the team. When you call the office, you'll often talk to Amanda who is the ringleader of the crew. She was always a joy to talk to and made sure to get us in touch with the right person or answer our question right on the spot. She knew every aspect of our transaction and was always happy to help in any way possible. Circling back to the team as a whole, they are the total package. I have referred many friends their way over the years and will continue to shout their names from the rooftops for the rest of time. Thank you Spencer Real Estate Group for being the best in the business; you're more remarkable than you know!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Helped me buy home • 2022

We absolutely loved working with Spencer and his team. As first time home buyers, we were a bit overwhelmed just thinking about the home buying process. Spencer and his team were so kind and walked us through every step of the way! The team at Spencer Real Estate Group answered all of questions in a timely manner and were just as excited as we were when we landed the perfect house (for a great price)! I cannot recommend them enough!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Spencer Schumacher

Listed and sold a home • 2022

Working with Spencer and his team was the best decision my wife and I made when selling our home in Sun Prairie. The expertise and efficiency of Spencer's office led to us accepting an offer three days after putting our home up for sale. The weekly meetings between the accepted offer and the closing appointment made the process extremely easy as well. You will be in great hands with Spencer and his team!

Compare similar top real estate agents nearby

  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Matt Winzenried Real Estate Team

    Realty Executives Cooper Spransy

    273 local sales

    4.9137 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Jo Ferraro Real Estate Team

    EXP Realty, LLC

    212 local sales

    5.020 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    The Team

    EXP Realty, LLC

    206 local sales

    5.04 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Acker Maly Home Team

    RE/MAX Preferred

    201 local sales

    View profile

Be sure to interview at least 2-3 agents to get the best possible fit for your situation and needs. Get personalized top agent recommendations here.

Spencer Schumacher: Rankings and sales metrics (Madison, WI)

Recent closed sales

128

  • #88 in Madison
  • #446 statewide in WI

Recent sales volume

$60.54M

  • #106 in Madison
  • #392 statewide in WI

Awards and badges

2025 Top Agent Madison, WI
Top producer

Recent sales metrics

A breakdown of performance metrics from verified closed transactions over the past two years. The local median shows typical results for agents in this market, so you can compare.

Metric Spencer Schumacher Local median
Sale-to-list (sell sides) 100.0% 100.0%
Days on market (sell sides) 57 58
Sale-to-list (buy sides) 100.0% 100.0%
Days on market (buy sides) 47 61

Find the best agents and rates near you

  • Provide some basic details about your sale or purchase
  • Get matched with 2-3 top local agents in minutes
  • Choose the best fit, save up to 50% on listing fees

Spencer Schumacher: Experience and specialties (all markets)

Client mix

45%

Home sellers

57 sales

55%

Home buyers

71 sales

Typical home sales price

$140K

Low

$440K

Typical

$1.6M

High

Count of recent sales by price range

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by price bracket, showing where most of their transactions fall.

Price range Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
≤$200K 2
$200K–$300K 17
$300K–$400K 27
$500K–$750K 32
$750K–$1M 11
$1M–$2M 1

Count of recent sales by property type

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by property type, showing their experience with single-family homes, condos, townhouses, and more.

Property type Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Multi-family homes 3
Townhouses 11
Condos 14
Commercial 0
Land 0
Mobile homes 0
Manufactured homes 0

Count of recent sales by specialty

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by specialty, showing experience with transaction types that require specialized knowledge or serve specific groups.

Specialty Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Properties with HOA 0
Investor deals 1
Military buyers 3
First-time buyers 7
Senior living community 0
New construction 4

Methodology

Each agent profile is built from a comprehensive analysis of verified real estate transactions, licensing data, and other public sources. Our goal is to make complex market information accessible and meaningful - helping you understand an agent's experience, performance, and focus areas in context.

We consolidate and interpret key data points that reflect how an agent operates in their local market, including:

  • Transaction volume and recency of activity
  • Balance of buyer- and seller-side representation
  • Sale speed compared with local averages
  • Pricing and negotiation outcomes
  • Years of experience and transaction consistency
  • Specialties across property types, price ranges, or client needs

Data, transparency, and updates

All data is drawn from verified public records and internal research. We clean, normalize, and cross-check information to ensure it reflects real-world activity as accurately as possible. Profiles are updated on an ongoing basis as new data becomes available. Our process evolves continuously to improve precision and depth of coverage.

Any customer reviews and ratings displayed on this profile are sourced from Zillow Group via the Zillow Bridge API. Reviews are refreshed regularly to reflect the most current data published on Zillow and may include reviews for team members associated with this agent.

Why this matters

Real estate decisions are personal and high-stakes. These profiles are designed to give you a factual, up-to-date snapshot of each agent's background and results - the kind of objective insight you can use to evaluate whether they're a strong match for your goals.

Are you Spencer Schumacher? Fill out this form to claim your profile or offer a correction.