About Carol Lehman - Lancaster, PA real estate agent
Carol Lehman is a top real estate agent in Lancaster, PA with Hostetter Realty LLC. They work with sellers and buyers and have closed at least 64 transactions over the past 12 months — 112 over the past two years. Carol Lehman's experience includes first-time homebuyers, sales involving HOAs, and luxury homes.
We just completed our 5th real estate transaction with The Lehman Team and each experience has been excellent! Carol & Greg are knowledgeable about the market, they give trustworthy advice, and are friendly, wonderful people to work with! They promptly answered questions we had and never pressured us into making decisions we weren't ready for. We would highly recommend their services to anyone buying or selling property!!
Carol was thorough and great to work with. We would use Carol again in a heartbeat. Thank you Carol for helping us find our forever home. We would recommend her and her team to anyone looking to buy a home.
Our experience with Carol, and the entire Lehman Team, was exceptional! From day one Carol was hard at work on our behalf, and she never let up throughout the process! Her recommendations were spot on, she kept in contact and her communication was excellent. We couldn't be happier with the entire experience and the outcome was exactly what we had hoped for - the perfect buyers for our home!!! We highly recommend Carol and The Lehman Team if you're looking to buy and/or sell your home - they are all amazing!!!
Loved working with The Lehman team. Carol was wonderful to work with. She was very helpful and honest. She is also able to hook you up with professionals to help with repairs or any type of work you might want done to your house whether buying or selling. The whole process went smoothly.
Carol took the time to show us many of houses before settling on one. She would make great recommendations and even tell us it's not the right house if she thought it wasn't. The details and responsiveness throughout the whole process made it a breeze to close on our first home. I would definitely recommend Carol and her team to anyone in the market for a home. Thank you Carol!
My husband and I were so glad we decided to use Carol when searching for our first house to buy. During the whole process she was easy to communicate with, listened to what we wanted and gave great advice. Her team along with her referrals were all wonderful! We are so thankful she made our first home-buying experience seamless!
Carol and her team were fabulous. They were quick to respond to our needs, making helpful suggestions as we moved forward. What could have been a highly stressful situation because so very simple under her guidance, freeing us to focus on the things we needed to do. Carol took the time to get to know what we wanted. The home we bought was not one we would have put on our list, but because Carol knew us and what we wanted so well, she suggested that we take a look at what has become our dream home. We could not have been more pleased!
Carol and Greg were a great team to work with on selling our house. They have a good understanding of the local market and helped to establish a realistic selling price. We had an agreement of sale in less than a week of listing. They were also helpful in working through negotiations with the buyer. They are honest and trustworthy, responsive and professional.
Carol knew exactly vwhat we were looking for, provided constant and accurate home candidates as we awaited our own sale, then brought us to our ideal home on search-visit day one. Carol expedited our financing and coordinated with our home realtor to make for a seamless process. Lastly, Carol provided us with reliable service businesses for home improvements. We highly recommend Carol and her company, they are ultimate professionals.
Helped me buy home • Lancaster Township, PA • 2018
Working with Carol was an absolute delight. She knows everything and everyone in Lancaster County and I have never met someone who knew so much about housing and the trends in the market. Finally, she got me everything I asked for in negotiations and hooked me up with a great broker and insurance agent. It was an awesome first time buying experience.
Carol Lehman: Rankings and sales metrics (Lancaster, PA)
Recent closed sales
112
#58 in Lancaster
#1,047 statewide in PA
Recent sales volume
$44.38M
#61 in Lancaster
#1,005 statewide in PA
Awards and badges
2025Top AgentLancaster, PA
Top producer
Recent sales metrics
A breakdown of performance metrics from verified closed transactions over the past two years. The local median shows typical results for agents in this market, so you can compare.
Metric
Carol Lehman
Local median
Sale-to-list (sell sides)
100.0%
100.0%
Days on market (sell sides)
46
49
Sale-to-list (buy sides)
100.0%
100.0%
Days on market (buy sides)
50
49
Find the best agents and rates near you
Provide some basic details about your sale or purchase
Get matched with 2-3 top local agents in minutes
Choose the best fit, save up to 50% on listing fees
Carol Lehman: Experience and specialties (all markets)
Client mix
57%
Home sellers
64 sales
43%
Home buyers
48 sales
Typical home sales price
$190K
Low
$372.5K
Typical
$832.5K
High
Count of recent sales by price range
A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by price bracket, showing where most of their transactions fall.
Price range
Transaction countCount
Share of totalShare
≤$200K
4
4.0%
$200K–$300K
27
24.0%
$300K–$400K
32
28.9%
$400K–$500K
26
23.0%
$500K–$750K
20
18.0%
$750K–$1M
3
3.0%
Count of recent sales by property type
A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by property type, showing their experience with single-family homes, condos, townhouses, and more.
Property type
Transaction countCount
Share of totalShare
Single-family homes
86
76.8%
Multi-family homes
3
2.7%
Townhouses
22
19.6%
Condos
1
0.9%
Commercial
0
0.0%
Land
0
0.0%
Mobile homes
0
0.0%
Manufactured homes
0
0.0%
Count of recent sales by specialty
A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by specialty, showing experience with transaction types that require specialized knowledge or serve specific groups.
Each agent profile is built from a comprehensive analysis of verified real estate transactions, licensing data, and other public sources. Our goal is to make complex market information accessible and meaningful - helping you understand an agent's experience, performance, and focus areas in context.
We consolidate and interpret key data points that reflect how an agent operates in their local market, including:
Transaction volume and recency of activity
Balance of buyer- and seller-side representation
Sale speed compared with local averages
Pricing and negotiation outcomes
Years of experience and transaction consistency
Specialties across property types, price ranges, or client needs
Data, transparency, and updates
All data is drawn from verified public records and internal research. We clean, normalize, and cross-check information to ensure it reflects real-world activity as accurately as possible. Profiles are updated on an ongoing basis as new data becomes available. Our process evolves continuously to improve precision and depth of coverage.
Any customer reviews and ratings displayed on this profile are sourced from Zillow Group via the Zillow Bridge API. Reviews are refreshed regularly to reflect the most current data published on Zillow and may include reviews for team members associated with this agent.
Why this matters
Real estate decisions are personal and high-stakes. These profiles are designed to give you a factual, up-to-date snapshot of each agent's background and results - the kind of objective insight you can use to evaluate whether they're a strong match for your goals.
Are you Carol Lehman?Fill out this form to claim your profile or offer a correction.
