Top Realtors in Toledo, Ohio (2022 Rankings)

Kristy Snyder's Photo
By Kristy Snyder Updated September 3, 2023


Find the best real estate agents in Toledo

In a rapidly changing and volatile market, having a savvy real estate agent is more important than ever. The best realtors in Toledo can help you navigate tough markets and negotiate in your favor whether you're buying or selling.

But how do you begin your search for the right realtor — especially when there are over 387 active agents in Toledo? We analyzed 90 agents and curated the top 23. Learn how we narrowed down our top picks.

All of the agents here are highly rated, but if you'd like a more personalized recommendation, Clever Real Estate can help. Our full-service realtors work for well-known brokerages like Century 21 and Keller Williams and offer in-depth local expertise for both buyers and sellers.

Best of all, our service is free — no strings attached! Want to see how it works? Submit your info now to get your agent matches sent straight to your inbox.

Top agents in Toledo, OH for buyers

When selecting the best buyer's agents, we looked for:

  • Frequency with which they worked in the area recently, to understand familiarity
  • Consistent discounts off the list price when representing buyers
  • Positive reviews that indicated a willingness to give you the time and space to make a decision

Top agents in Toledo, OH for sellers

When selecting the best listing agents, we looked for:

  • Consistent professional photography and well-written listing descriptions
  • An ability to get top dollar for properties and low discounts accepted by sellers
  • Reviews that indicated their willingness to go the extra mile for transactions

Listing agents in Toledo — including the ones above — usually charge around 2–3% of your home sale price for their services. However, you can get an expert, full-service agent for just 1.5% when you work with Clever Real Estate. We pre-negotiate low commission rates with top agents in the area so you can save thousands on your transaction.

Find out how much you can save by using a Clever agent!

Top agents in Toledo, OH for upsizing

When selecting an agent that can help with buying and selling we considered:

  • History of handling multiple transactions for a client
  • Record of negotiating good deals for buyers and sellers
  • Specialization in a particular area and price range

Top agents in Toledo, OH for investing

When choosing the best agent to help you invest, we considered:

  • Experience working with other investors
  • Knowledge of the local market and any opportunities
  • Reviews that indicated the agent had many connections in the real estate industry

Looking for the best agent for you?

Don’t see an agent who is right for your situation? Speak with our Concierge Team to get hand-picked agent matches for you. Our service is free with no obligation.

Most experienced real estate agents in Toledo

Choose an experienced agent if you:

  • Expect a complex transaction
  • Need to buy or sell multiple properties
  • Want access to references (like contractors)

Highest rated real estate agents in Toledo

Pick a highly reviewed agent in your area if you:

  • Worry about going through the real estate process
  • Want to receive exceptional personal service
  • Are buying or selling a home for the first time

Agents in Toledo with the highest transaction volume

Your best choice is an agent with the most sales if you:

  • Have a very unique property
  • Want a large track record to evaluate their performance
  • Need advice on the local market

Most Transactions Number of Transactions Phone Number
The Tyo-Mathias Team 1,547 (419) 509-9386
Heather Smith-LaPoint 1,169 (419) 360-0922
Jon Simonton 920 (419) 320-2253
Dan Novotny 566 (419) 500-0129
Tammy Frye 561 (567) 349-4292
Show more

A high number of transactions is a good sign, but it may also indicate that an agent has too many clients to give you their full attention. If you want an agent who's dedicated to helping you find your dream home today, Clever Real Estate can help.

Plus, eligible buyers who use a Clever partner agent could earn cash back when they buy a home!

Get hand-matched with a buyer's agent now!


Agents Considered Sales Analyzed Factors Considered Hours Invested
90 730 10 30
Show more

The best real estate agents have a few things in common. They are all experienced, receive frequent positive reviews, get their clients consistent results, and usually specialize in an area, price point, or type of client.

The factors we consider when evaluating the top realtors in Toledo include:

  • Experience: The number of years an agent has worked and the number of transactions they’ve completed in that time
  • Reviews: How consistently and frequently the agent receives positive reviews
  • Results: How frequently an agent’s skill set benefits their clients
  • Specialization: The degree to which an agent works within a specific price range, area, or with buyers, sellers, or investors

Why trust us?

Clever Real Estate is a free agent-matching service that has helped more than 82,000 people buy and sell homes. We partner with over 2,700 top-performing agents nationwide at national brokers including Keller Williams, RE/MAX, Century 21, and more. We also offer eligible buyers cash back after closing.

We’ve earned buyers’ trust with a rating of 4.9 out of 5 starts on Trustpilot and over 1,800 customer reviews.

Our team of industry-leading researchers are committed to making homeownership more accessible by educating buyers through guides like this one. We've spent thousands of hours analyzing publicly available data, surveying consumers, and interviewing industry experts. Our research has been featured in The New York Times, Business Insider, Inman, Housing Wire, and many more.

Learn more about Clever.

Frequently asked questions

What is the average real estate agent commission in Toledo?

In Ohio, the combined average commission rate for the buyer's and seller's agent is 5.8%. That's more than the national average of 5.5%. Clever's average commission rate is lower than both of these at 3.9%. Learn more about the average commission rates in Ohio so you can find the best ways to save.

Why is it important to work with a top real estate agent in Toledo?

For sellers, a good real estate agent will get you the best possible price, provide top-notch suggestions for contractors and service providers, and even help you close faster. For buyers, they offer local market expertise, insider access to up-and-coming lists, and negotiation skills that can score you a good deal. Learn how to find a great agent to be on your team.

Additional resources

Better real estate agents at a better rate

Enter your zip code to see if Clever has a partner agent in your area
If you don't love your Clever partner agent, you can request to meet with another, or shake hands and go a different direction. We offer this because we're confident you're going to love working with a Clever Partner Agent.