Carolina's Choice Real Estate: Review & Ratings (September 2025)

Jamie Ayers's Photo
By Jamie Ayers Updated August 20, 2025
+ 2 more
Jamie Ayers's Photo's Photo
Reviewed by Ben Mizes Edited by Andrew Whytock

SHARE

$
We used the national median home value of $468,559 to estimate savings. Enter your home value for a personalized estimate.

Where Carolina's Choice Real Estate is available in North Carolina

Select your local market to compare all discount realtors near you.

Similar low commission real estate companies nearby

Overall rating for Carolina's Choice Real Estate

4.1
4.6
4.9
Range of scores for companies like Carolina's Choice Real Estate

Our expert take: Recommended

We strongly recommend considering Carolina's Choice Real Estate if you're looking for a full-service support discount real estate brokerage. It received excellent scores for customer satisfaction and sales performance.

Be sure to interview at least 1-2 other agents in addition to Carolina's Choice Real Estate to get the best possible fit for your situation and needs. Compare top local discount realtors here.

Customer experience:
5.0

Carolina's Choice Real Estate has an exceptional 5.0 customer experience score, which reflects consistently high customer satisfaction over its lifetime. We calculated a weighted average rating of 4.9 from 668 verified reviews. 99% of reviewers said they would recommend the company to others. Ratings have slipped in recent months, from 4.9 to 4.7.

Pricing and fees:
4.0

Carolina's Choice Real Estate has a 4.0 pricing and fees score. This suggests decent savings potential, though its rates are closer to average among discount brands.

Fee typeHybrid (upfront + flat)
Flat fee at closing$3,000
Upfront flat fee$1,000
Sell and buy savingsNone identified
Buyer rebateNone identified
Transaction coordination feeNone identified

Services and support:
4.4

Carolina's Choice Real Estate has a 4.4 services and support score, which is solid relative to similar discount brokerages. It provides most of what we expect from a full-service brokerage — including a dedicated agent, in-person representation, MLS syndication, and professional photography. It also offers non-standard features like virtual tours and drone photography, which can help listings stand out.

Dedicated agent
In-person representation
MLS listing & syndication
CMA & pricing strategy
Professional photography
Offers & negotiating assistance
Paperwork & contract support
Closing support
House showing coordination
Yard sign
Lockbox for door
Digital marketing
Social media advertising
Virtual tours
Drone photography
Digital floorplans
Staging assistance
Print marketing
Open house hosting
Buyer showing attendance

Track record:
5.0

Carolina's Choice Real Estate has an excellent 5.0 track record score (top 15% compared to similar companies). We were able to verify activity dating back at least 14 years, which is about 6 years longer than the typical discount real estate broker. Carolina's Choice Real Estate has had very consistent new activity each month over its lifespan, a strong signal that it’s a stable and legitimate operation.

Carolina's Choice Real Estate vs. similar discount real estate brokerages

Company
Overall rating
Listing fee
Avg customer rating
Active since
4.6
Recommended
$4,000
4.9 (668)
2011
4.9
Top-rated
1%
4.9 (140)
2014
4.9
Top-rated
$3,000
4.8 (188)
2011
4.7
Recommended
1.5%
5.0 (2)
2021

Customer reviews for Carolina's Choice Real Estate

Rating summary

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.9668
Google4.9234
Zillow4.9428
Yelp4.36

Rating breakdown

5 star
97%(651)
4 star
1%(7)
3 star
0%(1)
2 star
0%(0)
1 star
1%(9)

Explore more ways to sell your house

Methodology

Clever reviews and rates discount real estate brokers across the U.S. based on four key factors: customer experience, pricing, services, and track record.

Each company’s score reflects a combination of quantitative data (like review trends and pricing structure) and verified service information. We independently assess how well a company delivers value, support, and savings compared to other full-service brokerages in the same market.

Our scoring model weights each factor based on its importance:

  • Customer Experience (35%) — Do past clients recommend the company? Are recent reviews positive and consistent?
  • Pricing & Fees (30%) — How much does the service cost relative to other brokers? Are there rebates or discounts?
  • Services & Support (20%) — Does the company offer the same level of service as a traditional agent? Any extras?
  • Track Record (15%) — How long has the company been active, and how steady is their review activity over time?

We regularly update our data and rankings to reflect the most recent information, helping you find the best mix of support and savings for your needs.

Better real estate agents at a better rate

Enter your zip code to see if Clever has a partner agent in your area
If you don't love your Clever partner agent, you can request to meet with another, or shake hands and go a different direction. We offer this because we're confident you're going to love working with a Clever Partner Agent.