9 Best Cash Home Buyers in Indianapolis, Indiana

Chelsi Hewitt's Photo
By Chelsi Hewitt Updated April 11, 2024
's Photo
Edited by Lindsay Stefan

SHARE

We ranked 9 cash buyers who buy homes in the Indianapolis, Indiana area. Read on for the full list of companies, or use our tool to compare cash offers from vetted buyers in your zip code.

About cash home buyers (read more)
  • Companies that buy houses for cash buy almost any Indianapolis property, including homes that need repairs or homes with complicating factors, like title issues or tax defaults, that could make a regular sale difficult.
  • Cash home buyers typically pay in cash, so they can often help you sell your house faster than a conventional buyer who has to wait to get approved for a mortgage — sometimes within just a few days.
  • Buying complicated properties quickly brings a lot of risk, so these investors typically pay less for homes than you would get in an open market sale, to ensure they don’t end up taking a loss.
  • This tradeoff can be well worth it for sellers who need speed, certainty, privacy, or problem-solving to get a deal done. Just make sure to thoroughly vet any cash home buyer and get multiple offers to compare. It's also worth considering alternatives like selling with a low commission realtor.
Cash home buyer alternatives (read more)
  • If you need to sell fast or on a very specific timeline and your home is relatively new and in good condition, you may want to consider an iBuyer instead. iBuyer companies offer similar speed and flexibility but pay closer to fair-market value.
  • If you have a bit of timeline flexibility, it’s worth finding a real estate agent to get a free comparative market analysis so you know what you could get for your home on the open market. Listing with an agent means less control over timing but will generally net you the most money in the end.

Top companies that buy houses for cash in Indianapolis, Indiana

Company
Customer Rating
TrustScore
BBB Status
Active Since
4.9
60 reviews
83
🟢 Recommended
Accredited, A+
2022
5.0
155 reviews
72
🔵 Worth considering
Not accredited, A+
2017
4.7
151 reviews
71
🔵 Worth considering
Not accredited, A+
2017
4.6
211 reviews
70
🔵 Worth considering
Accredited, A
2015
4.1
49 reviews
69
🔵 Worth considering
Accredited, A+
2016
4.6
70 reviews
56
🟣 Safe to consider
Not accredited
2016
4.0
16 reviews
55
🟣 Safe to consider
Not accredited, A
2022
5.0
28 reviews
55
🟣 Safe to consider
Not accredited, A+
2018
4.9
15 reviews
60
🔵 Worth considering
Accredited, A+
2020

Explore all Indianapolis, Indiana cash home buyers

Indianapolis cash home buyer

Heritage Cash Home Buyers

Visit Site
4.9
60 reviews

TrustScore

83

BBB Status

Accredited, A+

Active Since

2022

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: 8 reviews and 5 average rating in past 6 months | Excellent 4.9 rating with 60 reviews | BBB accredited with A+ rating and complaints | Active for more than 3 years, with 29 months of verified activity

Potential concerns: Website missing important credibility signals

Clever TrustScore 83 🟢 Recommended 
Customer score 100
Total reviews 60
Average rating 4.9
Review response rate 98%
7-day response rate 97%
BBB score 100
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints Unverified
Activity score 100
Reviews in past 6 months 8
Average rating in past 6 months 5.0
Months since last review 2
Track record score 63
Total number of months active 29
% of total months with activity 59%
Website credibility score 40
Names No
Photos No
Testimonials Yes

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.960
Google5.059
BBB1.01

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 133 W Market St Suite 273, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Website: heritagebuyshomes.com

Phone: (317) 751-7011

Additional Info: Identifies as Latino-owned; Identifies as women-owned; Offers online appointments; Offers onsite services

Indianapolis cash home buyer

RE/MAX Advanced Realty

Visit Site
5.0
155 reviews

TrustScore

72

BBB Status

Not accredited, A+

Active Since

2017

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: 52 reviews and 5 average rating in past 6 months | Excellent 5 rating with 155 reviews | Active for more than 8 years, with 90 months of verified activity | New customer review activity in 33% of months

Potential concerns: Responds to a low percentage of customer reviews | Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Not BBB accredited | Irregular or inconsistent verifiable company activity

Clever TrustScore 72 🔵 Worth considering 
Customer score 75
Total reviews 155
Average rating 5.0
Review response rate 35%
7-day response rate 13%
BBB score 70
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints 0
Activity score 100
Reviews in past 6 months 52
Average rating in past 6 months 5.0
Months since last review 0
Track record score 75
Total number of months active 90
% of total months with activity 33%
Website credibility score 60
Names Yes
Photos Yes
Testimonials No

RatingTotal reviews
Overall5.0155
Google5.0155

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 8313 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46234

Website: indianapolisrealestate.com

Phone: (317) 298-0961

Additional Info: Identifies as veteran-owned; Offers online appointments; Offers onsite services

Indiana cash home buyer

Midwest Cash Offer

Visit Site
4.7
151 reviews

TrustScore

71

BBB Status

Not accredited, A+

Active Since

2017

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: 32 reviews and 5 average rating in past 6 months | Very good 4.7 rating with 151 reviews | Active for more than 8 years, with 87 months of verified activity | New customer review activity in 48% of months

Potential concerns: Responds to a low percentage of customer reviews | Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Not BBB accredited

Clever TrustScore 71 🔵 Worth considering 
Customer score 69
Total reviews 151
Average rating 4.7
Review response rate 38%
7-day response rate 23%
BBB score 65
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints 2
Activity score 100
Reviews in past 6 months 32
Average rating in past 6 months 5.0
Months since last review 0
Track record score 88
Total number of months active 87
% of total months with activity 48%
Website credibility score 60
Names Yes
Photos Yes
Testimonials No

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.7151
Google4.7149
BBB1.02

Availability: Statewide

Business Address: 2001 E 52nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46205

Website: midwestcashoffer.com

Phone: (317) 707-4110

Indianapolis cash home buyer

Ben Buys Indy Houses

Visit Site
4.6
211 reviews

TrustScore

70

BBB Status

Accredited, A

Active Since

2015

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: 28 reviews and 4.5 average rating in past 6 months | Good 4.6 rating with 211 reviews | BBB accredited with A rating and 2 complaints | Active for more than 10 years, with 106 months of verified activity

Potential concerns: Website missing important credibility signals

Clever TrustScore 70 🔵 Worth considering 
Customer score 81
Total reviews 211
Average rating 4.6
Review response rate 82%
7-day response rate 65%
BBB score 90
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A
BBB complaints 2
Activity score 92
Reviews in past 6 months 28
Average rating in past 6 months 4.5
Months since last review 0
Track record score 100
Total number of months active 106
% of total months with activity 72%
Website credibility score 0
Names No
Photos No
Testimonials No

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.6211
Google4.7205
BBB2.26

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 1075 Broad Ripple Ave #231, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Website: benbuysindyhouses.com

Phone: (317) 455-6768

Additional Info: Offers online appointments; Offers onsite services

Beech Grove cash home buyer

Christopher Ellyn Homes

Visit Site
4.1
49 reviews

TrustScore

69

BBB Status

Accredited, A+

Active Since

2016

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: Mediocre 4.1 rating with 49 reviews | BBB accredited with A+ rating and complaints | Active for more than 9 years, with 95 months of verified activity | New customer review activity in 37% of months

Potential concerns: Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Website missing important credibility signals | Irregular or inconsistent verifiable company activity | Few customer reviews in last 6 months

Clever TrustScore 69 🔵 Worth considering 
Customer score 70
Total reviews 49
Average rating 4.1
Review response rate 88%
7-day response rate 35%
BBB score 100
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints Unverified
Activity score 26
Reviews in past 6 months 0
Average rating in past 6 months N/A
Months since last review 6
Track record score 75
Total number of months active 95
% of total months with activity 37%
Website credibility score 40
Names No
Photos No
Testimonials Yes

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.149
Google4.248
BBB1.01

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 342 N 17th Ave, Beech Grove, IN 46107

Website: christopherellynhomes.com

Phone: (317) 782-5481

Indianapolis cash home buyer

We Buy Indy Houses

Visit Site
4.6
70 reviews

TrustScore

56

BBB Status

Not accredited

Active Since

2016

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: 15 reviews and 4.7 average rating in past 6 months | Good 4.6 rating with 70 reviews | Active for more than 9 years, with 92 months of verified activity | New customer review activity in 24% of months

Potential concerns: Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Website missing important credibility signals | Not BBB accredited | Poor BBB rating

Clever TrustScore 56 🟣 Safe to consider 
Customer score 76
Total reviews 70
Average rating 4.6
Review response rate 79%
7-day response rate 33%
BBB score 50
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating NR
BBB complaints 0
Activity score 92
Reviews in past 6 months 15
Average rating in past 6 months 4.7
Months since last review 1
Track record score 75
Total number of months active 92
% of total months with activity 24%
Website credibility score 0
Names No
Photos No
Testimonials No

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.670
Google4.670

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 2247 Real Quiet Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46234

Website: webuyindyhouses.com

Phone: (317) 223-3195

Additional Info: Offers onsite services

Indianapolis cash home buyer

Simple Cash Offers

Visit Site
4.0
16 reviews

TrustScore

55

BBB Status

Not accredited, A

Active Since

2022

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: Mediocre 4 rating with 16 reviews | Active for more than 3 years, with 29 months of verified activity | New customer review activity in 34% of months | Excellent transparency signals on website

Potential concerns: Responds to a low percentage of customer reviews | Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Not BBB accredited | Irregular or inconsistent verifiable company activity

Clever TrustScore 55 🟣 Safe to consider 
Customer score 38
Total reviews 16
Average rating 4.0
Review response rate 6%
7-day response rate 0%
BBB score 60
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A
BBB complaints 3
Activity score 0
Reviews in past 6 months 0
Average rating in past 6 months N/A
Months since last review 12
Track record score 50
Total number of months active 29
% of total months with activity 34%
Website credibility score 100
Names Yes
Photos Yes
Testimonials Yes

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.016
Google4.016

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 61 N Devon Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Website: simplecashhomeoffers.com

Phone: (317) 342-5228

Indianapolis cash home buyer

I Buy Indy Houses

Visit Site
5.0
28 reviews

TrustScore

55

BBB Status

Not accredited, A+

Active Since

2018

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: Excellent 5 rating with 28 reviews | Active for more than 7 years, with 78 months of verified activity

Potential concerns: Responds to a low percentage of customer reviews | Does not respond quickly to customer reviews | Website missing important credibility signals | Not BBB accredited

Clever TrustScore 55 🟣 Safe to consider 
Customer score 63
Total reviews 28
Average rating 5.0
Review response rate 0%
7-day response rate 0%
BBB score 70
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints 0
Activity score 0
Reviews in past 6 months 0
Average rating in past 6 months N/A
Months since last review 14
Track record score 50
Total number of months active 78
% of total months with activity 13%
Website credibility score 40
Names No
Photos No
Testimonials Yes

RatingTotal reviews
Overall5.028
Google5.028

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 11715 Fox Rd Suite 400 #135, Indianapolis, IN 46236

Website: ibuyindyhouses.net

Phone: (317) 537-1354

Indianapolis cash home buyer

Sell to Neil

Visit Site
4.9
15 reviews

TrustScore

60

BBB Status

Accredited, A+

Active Since

2020

At a glance

Full analysis

Reviews

Company info

Things to know: Excellent 4.9 rating with 15 reviews | BBB accredited with A+ rating and 0 complaints | Active for more than 5 years, with 54 months of verified activity | Responds to 67% of customer reviews within 7 days

Potential concerns: Responds to a low percentage of customer reviews | Limited verifiable company track record | Irregular or inconsistent verifiable company activity | No customer reviews in over 6 months

Clever TrustScore 60 🔵 Worth considering 
Customer score 55
Total reviews 15
Average rating 4.9
Review response rate 67%
7-day response rate 67%
BBB score 100
Has BBB profile Yes
BBB accredited Yes
BBB rating A+
BBB complaints 0
Activity score 0
Reviews in past 6 months 0
Average rating in past 6 months N/A
Months since last review 40
Track record score 38
Total number of months active 54
% of total months with activity 17%
Website credibility score 60
Names Yes
Photos Yes
Testimonials No

RatingTotal reviews
Overall4.915
Google4.915

Availability: Marion County area

Business Address: 4040 S Meridian St Suite #19, Indianapolis, IN 46217

Website: selltoneil.com

Phone: (317) 721-7355

Additional Info: Offers online appointments; Offers onsite services

Next steps: Start requesting cash offers

Compare cash offers in minutes
  • Answer 5 simple questions about your sale
  • Get competitive cash offers from fully vetted buyers
  • Compare all your options with zero pressure or obligation
Get Cash Offers

Related articles and resources

What you should know about cash home buyers

  • Cash home buyers can be useful if you have a complicated home sale, you want to sell your house fast, you've inherited a house, or you have goals that would be difficult to achieve selling with a real estate agent on the open market. Your options, offer prices, and closing speed will depend on your situation.
  • You may need to contact numerous cash buyers to get workable offers. Cash buyers are investors with varying budgets, goals, and constraints. Some will pay cash for almost any home under any circumstance at any time. Others specialize in locations, price ranges, property types, or situations. 
  • Cash offers will be unique to your home. How much "we buy houses for cash" companies will pay — and how fast they can close — depends on the home and situation. Investors can pay more for turnkey properties than those in need of major repairs. 
  • The selling process is condensed. Some companies that buy houses for cash can close deals within 2–3 days. However, Chesapeake houses with complicated legal issues could take months to close.
  • Most cash home buyers pay closing costs. You won't have to pay any unexpected fees on your closing date. Companies that buy houses for cash usually factor the seller's closing costs into their offer. 
  • Requesting a cash offer is always free, and there’s zero obligation to accept it. You may not get the fair market value many sellers get using a real estate agent. But you decide if you're offered a fair price and if the terms are acceptable based on your situation. If you feel pressured to accept an offer, walk away. If you suspect a scam or financial exploitation, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends you report it to the Federal Trade Commission and take these additional steps.

How to choose a cash home buyer and get good offers

  • Make sure the cash buyer is legit. Stick to buyers with credible websites that include owner information and video testimonials from real customers. Look for a solid number of legitimate positive customer reviews on established, external platforms like Google. Also, look for companies with Better Business Bureau (BBB) profiles accredited with A+ ratings. 
  • Verify the buyer has the funds. Ask the buyer for an official proof of funds (POF) letter from their bank. Experienced and legitimate cash home buyers will expect this question or provide the POF without you even asking. The cash buyer should also provide a sufficient earnest money deposit (usually 1–2% of the sale price) when you go under contract, which represents their commitment to the sale.
  • Get multiple cash offers. Just like when getting quotes from contractors or shopping for the best mortgage rates, getting several offers from legit "we buy houses for cash" companies to compare and choose from will help you get the best terms and outcome.

Selling a House As-Is: What You Need to Know: We share the main factors that affect how much you may gain (or lose) when you sell as-is.

10 Best Companies That Buy Houses for Cash: Our team spent hundreds of hours researching "we buy houses" companies and iBuyers. Many of these companies have local franchises throughout the nation. 

How we rank cash buyers

Data sources

Our research team evaluated 9 cash home buyers serving Indianapolis. It also compiled and analyzed 147,511 publicly available data points tied to past transactions, customer reviews, and more to evaluate each of the Indianapolis home buyers and create our final list and rankings.

Methodology

Our team used public business directories to identify every company serving the Indianapolis area calling itself a cash home buyer. We filtered that list and ranked the top options based on the following criteria: 

  • Credibility: Is the company a legitimate and safe option? Before we recommend any company, we assess its owners and/or team members, customer testimonial videos, Better Business Bureau status, total Google reviews, and the legitimacy of those reviews. 
  • Activity: Is the company actively buying a large number of homes? We consider Google and BBB reviews an indicator of sales activity. We examine how many reviews the company has had in the past six months and whether the company responds to its reviews. 
  • Satisfaction: Are sellers generally happy with their experience and outcome? We gauge how compassionate, helpful, fair, and reliable a cash home buyer is by evaluating its Google and BBB reviews for average rating, total reviews, and negative reviews.

Our team also highlighted the company's availability based on where it operates.

  • Local: Operates in Indianapolis
  • Statewide: Operates throughout Indiana
  • Multi-state: Operates throughout Indiana and at least one other state
  • Nationwide: Operates in all states

✍️ Editor’s note: We don't disqualify a company for limited or missing data, but we do lower the company’s ranking. We base our rankings on objective measurements and can only measure what we see. We regularly search for missing data to update our rankings accordingly.

Clever Real Estate's content team created parts of this page with the assistance of an AI tool. Our team of humans researched the companies, collected and analyzed the data, and ranked the companies, then used AI to assist in writing about the companies. Our team fact-checked and edited the text, as it does for all of our content.

Better real estate agents at a better rate

Enter your zip code to see if Clever has a partner agent in your area
If you don't love your Clever partner agent, you can request to meet with another, or shake hands and go a different direction. We offer this because we're confident you're going to love working with a Clever Partner Agent.