Stillwater Properties: Review & Ratings (November 2026)

Written by Jamie Ayers +2 others
Edited by Andrew Whytock Reviewed by Ben Mizes
Written by Jamie Ayers Edited by Andrew Whytock Reviewed by Ben Mizes
Updated November 2, 2026
Property Investor
Property investor Direct buyer

Stillwater Properties

Stillwater Properties earns a strong overall score. It combines positive customer ratings with enhanced screening by our team.

Overall score

#8 of 36 similar

At a glance

Profile status
Enhanced
Avg rating
4.7 (50 reviews)
BBB status
Accredited, A+
Founded in
2020

About

Stillwater Properties is a Beloit-based cash home buyer in parts of Wisconsin. It's been in business since 2020 and identifies as family-owned. Direct sellers pay no fees, commissions, or closing costs.

Read the full bio

Offers & terms

Buys:
Single-family Poor Fair
Terms:
As-is Covers closing costs 7-day closings Cleanout services
Situations:
Divorce Downsizing Death in family Inheritance
See service details

Score breakdown

Customer experience Decent depth
Recent activity High activity · Accelerating
Credibility signals Strong trust signals
View full breakdown

Is Stillwater Properties legit?

Yes — our research suggests Stillwater Properties is a legitimate business. We found a claimed profile and enhanced screening with our team, BBB accreditation, 50 third-party reviews and review activity within the past year.

View verification checklist

Compare similar cash home buyers

Property investor
92

Captain Save A Home

Wisconsin property investor buying around Kenosha and Sheboygan. Also wholesales.

Read review
Property investor
90

Simply Sold RE

Cash property buyer in parts of NY, CT, PA, and WI. Buys condos and multifamily homes.

Read review
Property investor
90

Cash House Buyer WI

Cash buyer in parts of Wisconsin. Reports more than 500 home purchases.

Read review
Buy before you sell
83

Flyhomes

Access your home equity and financing to buy your next home before selling.

Read review

About Stillwater Properties

Company bio

Stillwater Properties is a cash home buyer based in Beloit, operating in parts of Wisconsin including Milwaukee, Madison, and Janesville. It's been in business since 2020 and identifies as family-owned. Rebecca Sullivan owns the company.

Its website says the founder spent ten years as a middle-school teacher before moving into real estate. The company says it makes its profit by renovating and reselling acquired homes. If a property meets its buying criteria, the team schedules an appointment before an offer. Sellers can skip repairs and cleaning and leave unwanted belongings for free hauling. Direct sellers pay no fees, commissions, or closing costs. Closings use a local title company, as quickly as seven days or on the seller's schedule.

Offers & terms

Property type(s)
Single-family
Condition(s)
Poor Fair
Terms & perks
As-is Covers closing costs 7-day closings Cleanout services Flexible closing
Seller situations
Divorce Downsizing Death in family Inheritance Probate Foreclosure Liens Vacant homes Fire damage

Where they buy

Choose a market to compare cash home buyers near you.

Ownership

Owners
Mac Sullivan · Mac T. Sullivan · Rebecca Sullivan
Based in
Beloit, WI
Founded
2020
Ownership
Family-owned

Operations

Business type
Cash home buyer
Business model
Direct purchase
Ownership structure
Independent operator
Operating scale
Southern WI

Our ratings & analysis

87

Overall score

#8 of 36 similar

61 92
87

Stillwater Properties has a strong overall score. It ranks 8th out of the 36 Wisconsin cash home buyers we’ve scored. Its customer ratings are positive overall, averaging 4.7 stars across 50 ratings. Recent review activity is 3.3x its lifetime pace, though that amounts to 13 reviews in the past 6 months. It has strong business credentials, including enhanced screening with our team.

Stillwater Properties vs. similar cash buyers

Swipe to compare

Metric This company
Stillwater Properties logo
Stillwater Properties
Overall score 87 92 90 90
Avg rating 4.7 (50 reviews) 5.0 (107 reviews) 4.9 (77 reviews) 4.9 (77 reviews)
Recent activity High High Medium High
Founded 2020 2014 2014 —
BBB status Accredited, A+ Accredited, A+ Accredited, A+ Not available in our data
Coverage Regional Regional Multi-state Regional
Company page Visit website Read review Read review Read review
86

Customer experience

Top 50% in WI

Median 84
Avg rating 4.7
Total reviews 50
6-month rating 4.9
6-month trend Improving

Stillwater Properties has a strong customer experience profile. Its lifetime feedback was mostly positive, backed by a moderate review record. In the latest 3 months, recent feedback was stronger, though the small recent sample limited confidence. Its Customer Experience score of 86/100 places it near the middle of comparable cash buyers serving multiple markets.

Lifetime ratings. Lifetime feedback was mostly positive: 50 rated reviews averaged 4.7/5, with 45 five-star ratings and 3 one-star ratings. Reviews dated back to 2020. Our methodology adjusts small rating samples toward the typical company rating, then maps the adjusted rating to a score and applies a small review-depth deduction that decreases as the record grows. Volume credit grows with every rating, with an additional small adjustment that grows fastest over the first few hundred ratings and then slows. It strengthens the distance from the neutral, sample-adjusted 4.5-star signal; this record received a 0.23% adjustment to that signal. This added 0.04 score points before the depth deduction and confidence limit.

Recent ratings. Recent feedback remained strongly positive. Ratings averaged 4.7 across 17 reviews over 12 months, 4.9 across 13 reviews over 6 months and 5.0 across 6 reviews over 3 months, through October 22, 2026.

Rating trends. Ratings improved. The 3-month average rose from 4.72 lifetime to 5.00 — up 0.28 stars, or 5.9%. The five-star share rose from 90.0% to 100.0%, up 10.0 percentage points. The improvement covered only 6 recent ratings, limiting confidence in a lasting change.

Common themes. Compassionate treatment led the feedback, appearing in 18 of 30 detailed customer reviews (60%), followed by a smooth process in 17 (57%) and good communication in 8 (27%). Reviews could mention multiple themes.

Review relevance. We classified 36 of 50 reviews (72%) as relevant to the home-selling experience. Another 6 concerned business partners, another business, neighbors and shareholders. We excluded 3 duplicate entries and 5 reviews with too little text from sentiment analysis. All 50 star ratings remained in the lifetime rating record.

86

Recent activity

Top 25% in WI

Median 60
Recent reviews 13
Latest review 10 days ago
Recent pace 3.3×
Momentum Accelerating

Company activity · As of October 22, 2026 — our latest collection date.

Stillwater Properties has recent review activity. Its recent review volume is higher than similar companies, and its 6-month review pace is accelerating, at 3.3× its lifetime average pace. The company received fewer reviews in the latest 3 months — 6 reviews versus 7 reviews in the preceding 3 months. The company also completed enhanced screening with our team. Its Activity score of 86/100 places it around the top 13% of comparable cash buyers serving multiple markets.

Recent review volume. The company received more reviews than similar companies across all 3 periods. We counted 17 reviews over 12 months, 13 over 6 months and 6 over 3 months. Similar companies had median counts of 5, 2, and 1, respectively.

Recent review pace. Its 6-month review pace is accelerating, at 3.3× its lifetime average pace. Its latest 3-month pace was 3.1×, compared with 2.2× over 12 months. Recent rates averaged 2.2 reviews per month over 6 months, 2 over 3 months and 1.4 over 12 months, versus a lifetime average of 0.6. The record contains 50 reviews dating back to 2020. A few reviews can noticeably change the recent pace.

Review freshness. Its latest review on file was October 12, 2026 — less than 2 weeks old as of our last data refresh. 26% of all reviews appeared within the last 6 months, and the average review age was about 1.5 years.

Other business activity. Stillwater Properties claimed its directory profile and completed enhanced screening with our team. We have no business interview or reviewed purchase figure on file.

95

Credibility signals

Top 25% in WI

Median 87
BBB status Accredited, A+
Verification status Enhanced
Reviews since 2020

Stillwater Properties has a very strong credibility profile (#4 of 37 in WI). We identified the company’s leadership, business structure, and buying model, supported by a broad online presence. BBB lists 2020 as the business-start year. We have 6 years of documented review history. The main limit on its score was website depth and transparency. We found no specific legitimacy concerns or review-integrity red flags in the retained source material, so there were no deductions.

Verification. We identified Google, BBB, Facebook, and Yelp profiles. The BBB records we reviewed list accreditation since 2022. They list an A+ rating. Its Google Business Profile was verified. Stillwater Properties claimed its directory profile and completed enhanced screening with our team.

Website assessment. The website was accessible when checked on September 29, 2026. The website scored 85/100 for depth and transparency. It includes company background, team information, buying and service information, the process and terms, and customer testimonials or work examples.

Business details. We identified Mac Sullivan as the company’s owner. The BBB records we reviewed identify Mac T. Sullivan as owner and Rebecca Sullivan as owner. BBB lists the business as an LLC. Its website identifies it as a direct buyer. BBB lists Stillwater Properties LLC as an alternate business name.

Track record. BBB lists June 1, 2020 as its business-start date, June 11, 2020 as its incorporation date, and October 25, 2022 as its profile-opening date. Reviews on file date back to June 22, 2020. Reviews appear in 26 of the 77 months covered by our records. The longest period without a recorded review was 22 months.

Complaints and red flags. No specific legitimacy concerns or review-integrity red flags were identified in the retained source material.

Verification checklist

5 of 5 baseline checks are supported by the evidence in our records.

Baseline checks

  • Business identity: Confirmed through Google Business Profile, BBB profile and BBB license or registration listing
  • Current business presence: Website accessible at last check; published phone number
  • Public feedback: 50 accepted third-party reviews
  • Established public history: Accepted review activity since 2020
  • Recent activity: 17 reviews in the recorded 12-month window; latest less than a month before collection

Additional verification

  • BBB status: Accredited, A+
  • License or registration: Listed in the BBB profile; issuer: Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services. Current status not independently checked.

Company-provided information

  • Claimed profile: The company claimed this profile
  • Enhanced screening: Company-reported business details received; not independently verified

Meeting these baseline checks is not a guarantee of current availability or a particular experience or transaction outcome. Compare offers, read reviews, and have a professional review any offers and contracts before moving forward.

Review explorer: Stillwater Properties

What reviewers say

30 substantive reviews Medium signal
Reviews most often praise Stillwater Properties for respectful treatment, a smooth process, and clear communication. We found no recurring negative pattern in the review text we analyzed.

Notable findings

  • 18 of 30 analyzed reviews (60%) mention respectful treatment, about 2x the typical rate for similar cash investors.
  • 17 of 30 analyzed reviews (57%) mention smooth process.
  • No recurring complaint pattern met our reporting threshold.

Reviews analyzed

50 public reviews

− 14 too short, irrelevant, or duplicate

− 6 relevant, but too general

30 detailed reviews with clear themes

Excluded: 6 outside the seller experience (e.g., business partners, neighbors or third parties); 5 with too little text to assess; 3 duplicates.

How reviews qualify

We identify themes from reviews that describe a specific experience with the service. General praise or criticism alone does not provide enough detail.

5 — No text or very short comments. No text or too little detail to assess the experience.

6 — Outside the experience assessed here. Reviews about something other than using the cash-offer or sell-fast service.

  • 1 — Neighbors or other third parties
  • 1 — Shareholders
  • 3 — Vendors or business partners
  • 1 — A different company

3 — Repeated review text. We count repeated text only once when identifying themes.

6 — General feedback without specifics. Relevant reviews that give general praise or criticism without describing a specific experience.

Review themes

Positive feedback

Respectful treatment (18 reviews) 60%

18 reviews mention respectful or compassionate treatment.

About 2x the typical rate
Smooth process (17 reviews) 57%

17 reviews describe the process as easy, smooth, or straightforward.

Communication (8 reviews) 27%

8 reviews praise communication or being kept informed.

Fast closing (6 reviews) 20%

6 reviews mention a fast or on-schedule closing.

Flexibility (6 reviews) 20%

6 reviews mention flexibility around timing or seller needs.

Fair offers (5 reviews) 17%

5 reviews say the offer or overall deal felt fair.

Next steps if you’re considering Stillwater Properties

Even with a well-supported company record, the quality of an individual offer comes down to its price, terms, and the entity responsible for closing.

  1. Get the complete offer in writing

    Confirm the purchase price, closing date, seller-paid costs, inspection or cancellation rights, and whether the contract can be assigned to another buyer.

  2. Verify who is buying your home

    Confirm the legal business name, request proof of funds, and identify the title or closing company. If the brand has multiple offices, verify which office or entity is responsible for your offer.

  3. Compare the likely net proceeds

    Request at least 2 cash offers when possible. If time allows, compare them with an estimate of what you could net from an as-is listing after fees, repairs, and carrying costs.

How Clever Offers works

Illustration of a homeowner comparing Cash offer, Cash + upside, and 7 Day Sold options with a Cash Offer Advisor
  1. Tell us about your home

    Share your property details and timeline. We find cash investors and other sell-fast solutions that fit your needs.

  2. Compare your offers

    Compare multiple cash offers alongside options like 7 Day Sold. Your Cash Offer Advisor helps you understand pricing, timing, and terms.

  3. Sell on your terms

    Choose your best fit and close on your timeline — or decline the offers. Requesting offers is always free, with no obligation or pressure.

Related guides and resources

How we researched and scored this company

Methodology

We research each company using its website, business profiles, and third-party customer reviews. We use company sources to understand its services and terms, and distinguish those claims from independent evidence. When available, we also draw on interviews with company representatives and sellers, and relevant public records.

When there is enough evidence, we calculate an overall score out of 100 using 3 categories:

  • Customer experience (67.5%) reflects customer satisfaction, based primarily on average customer ratings and the number of reviews supporting them.
  • Recent activity (20%) reflects recent review volume, how recently the company received a review, and how its recent review pace compares with its history. Reviews are a signal of activity, not a count of completed home purchases.
  • Credibility (12.5%) considers business verification, website transparency, public engagement, and documented operating history.

Use the company or location identified on this page when interpreting the evidence. A broader company record may not describe every local office. Review history is separate from the company’s founding date.

Limited evidence can restrict what we can assess. A company may appear without a score, and a small review sample may not represent a typical seller’s experience. Scores summarize the evidence available to us; they do not predict an offer price or guarantee a sale or service quality.

Sources

  1. Company website, website information up to date as of September 2, 2026; website content analysis completed September 4, 2026.
  2. Better Business Bureau, profile information up to date as of September 21, 2026; review data up to date as of September 21, 2026; complaint data up to date as of September 21, 2026; reviews checked for updates on October 22, 2026.
  3. Google, profile information up to date as of October 21, 2026; review data partially collected on October 21, 2026; reviews checked for updates on October 21, 2026.
  4. Enhanced screening completed via phone on September 8, 2025.