Agent portrait unavailable

Penny Crick

Top Agent

ERA FIRST ADVANTAGE REALTY, INC

Evansville, IN

Recent sales

217

Price range

$21K - $1.2M

Typical price

$309,900

Active since

N/A

About Penny Crick - Evansville, IN real estate agent

Penny Crick is a top real estate agent in Evansville, IN with ERA FIRST ADVANTAGE REALTY, INC. They work with sellers and buyers and have closed at least 99 transactions over the past 12 months — 217 over the past two years. Penny Crick's experience includes luxury homes, first-time homebuyers, and new construction.

Service areas

Reviews for Penny Crick

Real Estate Broker • ERA First Advantage • Evansville, IN

4.8 20 reviews on

Note: Some reviews may be for team members.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Helped me buy home • 2021

Exceptional experience! Penny and Grodie are GREAT real estate agents and wonderful people. I am very selective, and they were more than I could ask for. They are a delightful team to work with, every step of the way, from visiting the house for the 1st time til closing day (even post-closing as there was work to be done). I RECOMMEND Penny and Grodie wholeheartedly, you will have a great experience -and I don't say this lightly. I am a first time homeowner and had a really bad first experience on my 1st offer (different agent), so I was a little skeptical. Working with Penny and Grodie, who was referred by a friend, I felt I was their priority at all times -she is very responsive via email, text and phone. She met every box and more. She would point out irregularities of a house and let me know about them, she would tell me if that was worth fixing or not -very honest, they will look after you. I visited the house I bought several times and they would happily agree to meet me every time, they would come in advance to make sure it was ready when I arrived. The process was easy, they took care of everything and would answer ALL my questions. Integrity is something I valued over anything else, specially after my bad experience with the prior agent, and Penny and Grodie got it!If you are hesitant of which agent to work with, I fully encourage you to give them a call. You will know right away!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Helped me buy home • Murfreesboro, TN • 2021

Penny and Grodie were outstanding in making this process go so smoothly! They were knowledgeable, quick to respond to any of our requests and made this entire experience seamless. I cannot say enough positive things about their invaluable assistance in making this home purchase a total success! I would recommend them to anyone and everyone!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Helped me buy home • 2021

Penny and Grodie Crick are the reason my fiancé and I were able to move into our first condo together. They worked so well with us and were so patient and respectful. I highly recommend them.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Listed and sold a home • 2020

The Crick Team sold our home for listing price in four days. Later in 2020, after my mother passed away, their services were invaluable in selling her home for list price as well as reducing family stress during a difficult time. Their expertise, attention to detail, and depth of knowledge in navigating the complicated home buying and selling process is likely unmatched. If your are looking to buy or sell a home, and want to work with a family oriented team with deep roots in the Evansville area, I encourage you to contact the Crick Team.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Helped me buy and sell homes • Evansville, IN • 2020

They helped buy our new home and sell our old home. They listed our old home and got a lot more money than we anticipated due to their recommendations and marketing. Very knowledgeable, experienced, professional, and personal.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Listed and sold a home • 2020

The Crick Team at ERA First Advantage did a phenomenal job selling our condo. They were incredibly easy to work with, and we had complete faith in their ability to find the perfect buyer. Penny and Grodie were there when we needed them, gave us honest and clear guidance, brought in stellar experts to stage and photograph the property, and personally oversaw every step of the sales transaction. High honors to them!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Helped me buy and sell homes • 2019

We have bought two houses and sold one house with the help of Penny and Grodie. They were knowledgeable, professional, and honest with us throughout our experience. We would recommend them to anyone!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Listed and sold a home • 2019

Penny and Grodie Crick gave us outstanding service. They were extremely attentive to our every inquiry and request and made us feel as though we were their only client, giving us 100% of their attention. We highly recommend them to anyone looking for a realtor.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Listed and sold a home • 2019

Penny & Grodie were great to ease the process of selling our home. They both sat down with us several times to talk through each step of our homes sale and future purchase. We highly recommend using them for your future home buying/selling needs.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Penny and Grodie Crick

Listed and sold a home • 2019

They were well prepared as they knew the area, the homes for sale, and, also have huge following/referral base of people looking to buy new homes. We listed our home and had an offer on the table in approx. 12 hours. They were always 3 and 4 steps ahead of the whole process and kept us the Sellers and then the Buyers on the right track for a smooth Closing. Thank you very much Penny and Grodie Crick for all the help!

Compare similar top real estate agents nearby

  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Deanne S Naas

    F.C. TUCKER EMGE

    185 local sales

    5.049 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Michael W Melton

    ERA First Advantage Realty

    174 local sales

    5.0151 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Jerrod W Eagleson

    KELLER WILLIAMS CAPITAL REALTY

    183 local sales

    5.021 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Janice E Miller

    ERA FIRST ADVANTAGE REALTY, INC

    230 local sales

    5.010 reviews on
    View profile

Be sure to interview at least 2-3 agents to get the best possible fit for your situation and needs. Get personalized top agent recommendations here.

Penny Crick: Rankings and sales metrics (Evansville, IN)

Recent closed sales

217

  • #5 in Evansville
  • #107 statewide in IN

Recent sales volume

$75.23M

  • #5 in Evansville
  • #206 statewide in IN

Awards and badges

2025 Top Agent Indiana
2025 Top Agent Evansville, IN
Top producer
Negotiation expert

Recent sales metrics

A breakdown of performance metrics from verified closed transactions over the past two years. The local median shows typical results for agents in this market, so you can compare.

Metric Penny Crick Local median
Sale-to-list (sell sides) 100.0% 99.0%
Days on market (sell sides) 51 53
Sale-to-list (buy sides) 100.0% 99.0%
Days on market (buy sides) 39 51

Find the best agents and rates near you

  • Provide some basic details about your sale or purchase
  • Get matched with 2-3 top local agents in minutes
  • Choose the best fit, save up to 50% on listing fees

Penny Crick: Experience and specialties (all markets)

Client mix

66%

Home sellers

144 sales

34%

Home buyers

73 sales

Typical home sales price

$21K

Low

$309.9K

Typical

$1.2M

High

Count of recent sales by price range

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by price bracket, showing where most of their transactions fall.

Price range Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
≤$200K 51
$300K–$400K 46
$400K–$500K 27
$500K–$750K 26
$750K–$1M 8
$1M–$2M 3

Count of recent sales by property type

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by property type, showing their experience with single-family homes, condos, townhouses, and more.

Property type Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Multi-family homes 0
Townhouses 0
Condos 0
Commercial 0
Land 4
Mobile homes 0
Manufactured homes 0

Count of recent sales by specialty

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by specialty, showing experience with transaction types that require specialized knowledge or serve specific groups.

Specialty Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Properties with HOA 0
Investor deals 0
Military buyers 2
First-time buyers 31
Senior living community 0
New construction 4

Methodology

Each agent profile is built from a comprehensive analysis of verified real estate transactions, licensing data, and other public sources. Our goal is to make complex market information accessible and meaningful - helping you understand an agent's experience, performance, and focus areas in context.

We consolidate and interpret key data points that reflect how an agent operates in their local market, including:

  • Transaction volume and recency of activity
  • Balance of buyer- and seller-side representation
  • Sale speed compared with local averages
  • Pricing and negotiation outcomes
  • Years of experience and transaction consistency
  • Specialties across property types, price ranges, or client needs

Data, transparency, and updates

All data is drawn from verified public records and internal research. We clean, normalize, and cross-check information to ensure it reflects real-world activity as accurately as possible. Profiles are updated on an ongoing basis as new data becomes available. Our process evolves continuously to improve precision and depth of coverage.

Any customer reviews and ratings displayed on this profile are sourced from Zillow Group via the Zillow Bridge API. Reviews are refreshed regularly to reflect the most current data published on Zillow and may include reviews for team members associated with this agent.

Why this matters

Real estate decisions are personal and high-stakes. These profiles are designed to give you a factual, up-to-date snapshot of each agent's background and results - the kind of objective insight you can use to evaluate whether they're a strong match for your goals.

Are you Penny Crick? Fill out this form to claim your profile or offer a correction.