Sections: Expert take | Full analysis | Top competitors | Reviews | Is it legit? | FAQs
Fifth Avenue Property Group
Overall rating
| Customer score |
4 |
|---|---|
| Credibility |
4.7 |
| Track record |
5 |
| Recent activity |
4.6 |
Fifth Avenue Property Group is a we buy houses for cash company in Canonsburg, PA. Fifth Avnue Property Group buys homes in and around the Pittsburgh metro area. It's been in business since 2019.
Highlights
- 78% of 184 total reviewers would likely recommend to others.
- Verified activity dating back at least 7 years.
- Highly active buyer compared to similar companies (top 10%)
- Very consistent new monthly activity over past 7 years, indicating stable and legit operation.
Where Fifth Avenue Property Group buys homes📍
Select your local market to compare all cash home buyers available near you.
More ways to sell your house fast
-
✨ Best Overall
Clever Offers
Offers Marketplace⚡ Get Cash Offers Read reviewBest for: Most home sellers. Compare all cash offers and options in one place.
-
Homeward
iBuyerRequest Offer Read reviewBest for: People with homes in good condition who need to sell fast.
-
BuyBox
Cash InvestorRead review Visit websiteBest for: People with fixer-uppers or hard-to-sell homes who need to sell fast.
-
Knock
Bridge LoanRead review Visit websiteBest for: People with lots of equity tied up in their current home who need to move now.
-
Xome
Online AuctionRequest Offer Read reviewBest for: People with homes that need major repairs who have a few weeks or more to sell.
Overall rating for Fifth Avenue Property Group
📊 Our Overall Rating is based on a variety of data including customer reviews, credibility, service quality, and activity level. Learn more.
Our expert take:
We highly recommend contacting Fifth Avenue Property Group to request a cash offer if you need to sell a house fast that needs repairs or has other complicating factors. The company has verified recent activity and excellent customer ratings, plus a strong track record and credibility signals online.
Fifth Avenue Property Group has a 4.0 customer score, which is decent (top 20% compared to similar companies). We calculated a weighted average customer rating of 4.0 based on 184 verified reviews, signaling that most people who sell to Fifth Avenue Property Group are generally satisfied with their experience and outcome. Additionally, 78% of reviewers would likely recommend the company to others. Fifth Avenue Property Group's customer ratings have fallen in recent months - 2.3 vs. 4.1 for all reviews over its full lifespan - suggesting customer satisfaction is trending down.
Fifth Avenue Property Group has a great 4.7 credibility score (top 20% compared to similar companies). It's accredited with the BBB, has an A+ rating, and 7 complaints. Fifth Avenue Property Group's website features most of the credibility signals we look for when evaluating cash investors, like team member names and team member photos. It responds to reviews online 8% of the time, signaling at least some degree of investment in its online reputation.
Fifth Avenue Property Group has an excellent 5.0 track record score (top 20% compared to similar companies). It's been active for at least 2019, based on the data our team was able to verify. Fifth Avenue Property Group has very consistent new activity each month over its lifespan, a strong signal that it's a stable and legitimate operation.
Fifth Avenue Property Group has a very strong 4.6 recent activity score (top 10% compared to similar companies). It's had 67 new reviews in the past eighteen months. 11 of those reviews were posted within the past six months. The most recent verified review was posted about a month ago, suggesting the company is actively buying homes at this time.
Fifth Avenue Property Group vs. similar cash investors
Customer reviews for Fifth Avenue Property Group
| Rating | Total reviews | |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | 4.1 | 184 |
| 4.4 | 132 | |
| BBB | 3.7 | 45 |
| Yelp | 1.6 | 7 |
Is Fifth Avenue Property Group legit?
Yes, we think Fifth Avenue Property Group is legit. Fifth Avenue Property Group's TrustScore is Very Strong (100%). We have high confidence that companies with TrustScores above 90% are very safe and legitimate, far exceeding the baseline criteria we look for when evaluating brand credibility.
Verification status as of 04/16/2025:
- Advertises cash offers online: Yes
- Active website: Yes
- At least 1 year verified activity: Yes, 7+ years of verified activity
- At least 20 verified customer reviews: Yes, 184 reviews
- At least 4.0 average customer rating: Yes, 4.1 average rating
- At least 1 new review in past 6 months: Yes, 11 new reviews
- Evenly distributed review activity: Yes, consistent review activity over past 64 months
- Responds to customer reviews online: Rarely, 8% of the time
- Has BBB profile: Yes
- Active BBB accreditation: Yes
- BBB accredited for at least 12 months: Unverified
- BBB rating of at least B+: Yes, BBB rating is A+
- Verified name of owner(s): Yes, Matthew Simmons
- Verified business address: Yes, 3935 Washington Rd Suite 1301, Canonsburg, PA 15317
- Names of team members and/or owners on website: Yes
- Photos team members and/or owners on website: Yes
- Video testimonials from past customers on website: No
FAQs about cash home investors
Most companies that buy houses for cash in are professional real estate investors who purchase properties, fix them up, then resell or rent them out for a profit.
- Many property investors look to buy “distressed” homes (properties that need major repairs, have complex title or tax issues, or whose owners are under pressure to sell fast).
- Because investors usually pay with cash, they can close faster than retail buyers who need approval from a lender. Some can close in as few as 2-3 days after making an offer.
- Buying complicated properties fast carries a lot of risk, so investors typically pay less than you'd net on the open market to ensure they don't end up losing money on the deal.
- This tradeoff can be worth it if you need speed and certainty or can't sell your home on the open market.
- But cash investors aren't always your best or only option. We suggest trying an offers marketplace like Clever Offers, which brings you competing cash offers and other sell-fast solutions to compare so you get the best price and sale outcome.
Consider a cash home buyer company if you're selling a house that needs major repairs, has complicating factors (e.g., title problems, liens, tax issues), or are under pressure to sell your house fast because of pre-foreclosure, financial issues, or unexpected life changes.
If you need to sell fast and have a newer, well-maintained house, you may want to look into an iBuyer or Buy-Before-You-Sell (aka bridge loan) service, if they're available in your area. iBuyer and Bridge Loan services may help you get a higher price without sacrificing speed and certainty.
If you have a more flexible selling timeline, it’s worth finding a real estate agent to get a free comparative market analysis so you know what you could get for your home on the open market. Listing with an agent means less control over timing, but will generally net you the most money in the end — even if you're selling a house as-is.
Most "We Buy Houses for Cash" companies are legit. But there are definitely bad actors and frauds to watch out for. Here are some quick tips that can help you avoid potential scams or predatory buyers.
- Look for an established online presence. E.g., BBB accreditation with a high letter grade; excellent customer ratings and lots of reviews (including recent ones) on third-party platforms like Google; a legitimate-looking website with info about owners, customer testimonials, and other credibility signals.
- Always request offers from more than one cash buyer. This will help ensure, at minimum, that you get a fair price and, ideally, help you net the most possible cash in the end. (Note: Clever Offers makes this process fast, safe, and easy).
- Ask for a proof of funds letter along with the cash offer. Legit and experienced cash investors should be happy to provide this to you.
- Make sure all the key details are in the contract. The earnest money deposit, sale price, closing date, and other key terms should be clearly stated in the purchase agreement. If it’s not in writing, the buyer can make last minute changes or back out of the deal and you have zero recourse.
- ⚠️ DON’T call the phone numbers on those generic “Cash for Houses” signs posted by the side of the road, especially when there are no details about the company.
- ⚠️ WALK AWAY if the cash investor or company representative is getting aggressive, pushy, or making you uncomfortable in any way.
- ⚠️ NEVER wire anyone money or give out your personal financial information without professional representation or a licensed third-party (like an attorney or title company) involved.
🚨 Important: If you or someone you know has been in contact with or possibly taken advantage of by a company you think is a scam or fraud, please (a) report it to your local police via 911 and (b) all relevant government protection agencies online:
Explore more ways to sell your house
Methodology
If you’re under pressure to sell a house fast — especially one in need of major repairs — cash home buyer companies may be your best (or only) option. But in these situations, it can be hard to know who to trust.
Clever evaluates thousands of we buy houses for cash companies across the country to help you smoothly and successfully navigate what can often be a confusing and stressful process.
Our editorial team manually reviews, vets, and analyzes each cash home buyer company for key credibility and quality signals, including customer ratings, online profiles and reputation, track record, and recent activity.
We assign a weight to each of these factors carefully based on their relative importance. We then roll them up into an overall rating to efficiently convey a given company’s balance of trustworthiness, service quality, and likelihood of making a viable offer if you reach out.
We are continually adding more companies to our review library and update all of our data regularly. Our goal is to help you quickly identify all of the local options worth considering, request multiple offers, and get the best outcome for your specific situation or needs.