Agent portrait unavailable

Jill Rosentel

Top Agent

Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)

Ithaca, NY

Recent sales

23

Price range

$37K - $649K

Typical price

$325,000

Active since

N/A

About Jill Rosentel - Ithaca, NY real estate agent

Jill Rosentel is a top real estate agent in Ithaca, NY with Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown). They work with sellers and buyers and have closed 23 transactions over the past two years. Jill Rosentel is experienced with first-time homebuyers.

Agent info

License info

Name
Jill Rosentel
License
10301201202 (NY)

Reviews for Jill Rosentel

Warren Real Estate • Ithaca, NY

4.8 23 reviews on

Note: Some reviews may be for team members.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Showed me homes • Ithaca, NY • 2022

Jill is a phenomenal realtor, and I would recommend her to anyone house hunting in the Ithaca area. My fiance and I met Jill through a local first time home buyer course -- her interest in helping first time home buyers really stood out to us, especially in this highly competitive market. Jill was very knowledgeable about the Ithaca area, and showed us many homes. She was transparent about her process and openly expressed concerns she had about certain homes we saw. We never felt pressured to put in an offer on a house we were uncertain about. Jill also has a fun personality, which was awesome considering how much time is spent together throughout the search process. Part way through the process, my fiance and I decided to relocate outside of the Ithaca area, so we didn't end up buying a house while working with Jill. However, I am confident that if we stayed in the Ithaca area, Jill would have guided us through the closing process smoothly.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • Ithaca, NY • 2022

If you work with Jill, you’re going find out just how knowledgeable, confident, talented, dedicated, funny, and kind she is. It was her incredible skill and intuition that encouraged us to place a competitive bid on a wonderful house that we now own. I know so many Realtors have rave reviews from happy clients, but seriously, Jill is awesome and really good at what she does. Stop reading these reviews and go contact her already. Go!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • 2019

This was my first home buying experience. The entire process was seamless, and she was someone I could put my trust in to help me find a home that would fit both my personality and lifestyle. There was no rush to the home buying process, and I felt that I could go at my own pace to find what I wanted, as this was an enormous financial commitment. Jill came highly recommended by my landlord, and she was incredible to work with. Jill was both flexible and punctual when there was a house I wanted to visit. I am so incredibly happy with the house Jill was able to help me find.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • 2020

Jill Rosentel was fantastic to work with. She is extremely knowledgeable, listens to her client, and is masterful in getting the sale done. She is also very personable and friendly. Thanks Jill for all your help!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • Ithaca, NY • 2019

Jill has helped us buy two homes, our own and an investment property. Both experiences were great! Working with her is like hanging out with your friend who happens to be super knowledgeable about buying houses.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Listed and sold a home • 2019

We reached out to Jill Rosentel with the Carol Bushburg agency to get a sense of the value and salability of our home. Jill scheduled a meeting where we discussed the sale process, and the steps included in getting an idea of the market value of our home. We were pleased with our initial contact, and entered into a contract with Jill. While trying to determine the greatest value, Jill found that we were “unique” in that our home didn’t fit any of the categories which typically define a style or design. Jill shared some results of her search which we all agreed didn’t fit our description. Jill finally settled on what she thought was on the high side of a fair asking price, and we were thrilled. Jill made helpful suggestions of low cost changes we could make to enhance the appearance of the grounds as well as the residence. She offered hints on displaying certain items, and removing others from view during a showing. When we were “on the market”, Jill kept us informed with updates on a regular basis and was always upbeat about the potential for a sale. We received an offer, and Jill guided us along with what our options were, schedules we needed to meet, and what was expected of us as sellers. All in all we had a very positive experience. We sold our home for a much greater amount than we had anticipated and feel it was through Jills understanding of her job, her understanding of the market and her willingness to use all available resources to make a sale for her clients.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Listed and sold a home • 2019

Jill was our sellers agent, and she and her team at Carol Bushberg Real Estate did a fantastic job! Jill was incredibly easy to work with, gave helpful advice on how to prepare our home for listing, and really listened to us. She has extensive knowledge of the local market and knew exactly how to increase traffic to our home. We had an offer within four days and were very pleased with the entire process. Jill is impressive, and it's no wonder that she's held onto "Ithaca's Best Realtor" for years now.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • 2018

I had a wonderful experience with Jill. She is warm and friendly (and funny) and helped us negotiate with speed and ease. She helped connect me to other services in the community that fit my needs, and was adept at discussing the pros and cons of various choices that we needed to make in purchasing a home.

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • Ithaca, NY • 2018

Jill is fantastic! We were very apprehensive about buying in Ithaca because of how competitive the market is but with Jill helping navigate we had a smooth, dare I say effortless, experience. Here are just a few of the ways Jill rocks: She’s soooo down to earth, not sales-pitchy at all...she’s authentic. She really wants to understand her clients in order to help them find the right place. We were looking for a home with an accessory rental apartment and that had some need for improvements/updates. She knew the questions we needed to ask the sellers and the Village to be sure the apartment was rentable, etc. She worked with the seller’s agent to be sure some needed repairs were completed before the sale was finalized. And she gave us great suggestions for real estate service providers. I would absolutely look to Jill again as our real estate agent and would highly recommend her to anyone. By the way, we never saw anything in Jill that would indicate that negative reviewer has any clue what they’re talking about. Just call her. She’s awesome!

5.0
Source: Zillow Group

Review for member: Jill Rosentel

Helped me buy home • 2018

We had the best experience working with Jill! We really appreciated how she took the time to get to know us and understood exactly what we were looking for. We let her know when we'd be in town and she made it a priority to schedule time to lead us from place to place. We loved that she was patient and honest - pointing out things that she knew might be an issue down the road and encouraging us to take our time until we found the perfect fit for us. We finally found that perfect fit and couldn't be happier. We highly recommend working with Jill!

Compare similar top real estate agents nearby

  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Jordan L Jacobsen

    Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.

    21 local sales

    5.0101 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Karen Hollands

    Howard Hanna S Tier Inc

    26 local sales

    5.082 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Steven Saggese

    Warren Real Est(Ithaca/Seneca)

    29 local sales

    5.068 reviews on
    View profile
  • Agent portrait unavailable

    Colleen Dobbins Cowan

    Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.

    13 local sales

    View profile

Be sure to interview at least 2-3 agents to get the best possible fit for your situation and needs. Get personalized top agent recommendations here.

Jill Rosentel: Rankings and sales metrics (Ithaca, NY)

Recent closed sales

23

  • #11 in Ithaca
  • #9,962 statewide in NY

Recent sales volume

$8.14M

  • #16 in Ithaca
  • #23,696 statewide in NY

Awards and badges

2025 Top Agent Ithaca, NY
Top producer

Recent sales metrics

A breakdown of performance metrics from verified closed transactions over the past two years. The local median shows typical results for agents in this market, so you can compare.

Metric Jill Rosentel Local median
Sale-to-list (sell sides) 100.0% 98.5%
Days on market (sell sides) 102 97
Sale-to-list (buy sides) 100.0% 100.0%
Days on market (buy sides) 69 94

Find the best agents and rates near you

  • Provide some basic details about your sale or purchase
  • Get matched with 2-3 top local agents in minutes
  • Choose the best fit, save up to 50% on listing fees

Jill Rosentel: Experience and specialties (all markets)

Client mix

43%

Home sellers

10 sales

57%

Home buyers

13 sales

Typical home sales price

$37K

Low

$325K

Typical

$649K

High

Count of recent sales by price range

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by price bracket, showing where most of their transactions fall.

Price range Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
≤$200K 1
$300K–$400K 6
$400K–$500K 2
$500K–$750K 5

Count of recent sales by property type

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by property type, showing their experience with single-family homes, condos, townhouses, and more.

Property type Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Multi-family homes 2
Townhouses 0
Condos 0
Commercial 0
Land 0
Mobile homes 0
Manufactured homes 0

Count of recent sales by specialty

A breakdown of this agent's closed sales over the past two years by specialty, showing experience with transaction types that require specialized knowledge or serve specific groups.

Specialty Transaction countCount Share of totalShare
Luxury homes 0
Properties with HOA 0
Investor deals 0
Military buyers 0
Senior living community 0
New construction 0

Methodology

Each agent profile is built from a comprehensive analysis of verified real estate transactions, licensing data, and other public sources. Our goal is to make complex market information accessible and meaningful - helping you understand an agent's experience, performance, and focus areas in context.

We consolidate and interpret key data points that reflect how an agent operates in their local market, including:

  • Transaction volume and recency of activity
  • Balance of buyer- and seller-side representation
  • Sale speed compared with local averages
  • Pricing and negotiation outcomes
  • Years of experience and transaction consistency
  • Specialties across property types, price ranges, or client needs

Data, transparency, and updates

All data is drawn from verified public records and internal research. We clean, normalize, and cross-check information to ensure it reflects real-world activity as accurately as possible. Profiles are updated on an ongoing basis as new data becomes available. Our process evolves continuously to improve precision and depth of coverage.

Any customer reviews and ratings displayed on this profile are sourced from Zillow Group via the Zillow Bridge API. Reviews are refreshed regularly to reflect the most current data published on Zillow and may include reviews for team members associated with this agent.

Why this matters

Real estate decisions are personal and high-stakes. These profiles are designed to give you a factual, up-to-date snapshot of each agent's background and results - the kind of objective insight you can use to evaluate whether they're a strong match for your goals.

Are you Jill Rosentel? Fill out this form to claim your profile or offer a correction.